,1'(3(1'(17�(��0,1(5�6�5(3257 72�7�(�75867((6�2)
(9(5��1�7,21�0,1,675,(6��(/)�67� ��WKH�&RPSD����
, UHSRUW WR WKH FKDULW�WU�VWHHV R�P�H�DPL�DWLR�RI WKH DFFR��WV RI WKH &RPSD��IRU WKH �HDU H�GHG ��2FWREHU ���� R��SDJHV���WR����IROOR�L�J���KLFK�KDYH�EHH��SUHSDUHG�R��WKH�EDVLV�RI�WKH�DFFR��WL�J�SROLFLHV�VHW�R�W�R��SDJHV���D�G���
5HVSR�VLELOLWLHV�D�G�EDVLV�RI�UHSRUW
�V WKH FKDULW��V WU�VWHHV RI WKH &RPSD���D�G DOVR LWV GLUHFWRUV IRU WKH S�USRVHV RI FRPSD��OD���R�DUH UHVSR�VLEOH IRU�WKH�SUHSDUDWLR��RI�WKH�DFFR��WV�L��DFFRUGD�FH��LWK�WKH�UHT�LUHPH�WV�RI�WKH�&RPSD�LHV��FW��������WKH�������FW���
-
�DYL�J VDWLVILHG P�VHOI WKDW WKH FKDULW�LV �RW V�EMHFW WR D�GLW ��GHU FRPSD��OD��D�G LV HOLJLEOH IRU L�GHSH�GH�W H�DPL�DWLR���LW�LV�P��UHVSR�VLELOLW��WR�
-
L� H�DPL�H�WKH�DFFR��WV���GHU�VHFWLR�����RI�WKH�&KDULWLHV��FW LL� IROOR�WKH SURFHG�UHV ODLG GR��L�WKH JH�HUDO 'LUHFWLR�V JLYH�E�WKH &KDULW�&RPPLVVLR�IRU 1RUWKHU�,UHOD�G ��GHU�VHFWLR��������E��RI�WKH�&KDULWLHV��FW
LLL�VWDWH��KHWKHU�SDUWLF�ODU�PDWWHUV�KDYH�FRPH�WR�P��DWWH�WLR��
�DVLV�RI�L�GHSH�GH�W�H�DPL�HU�V�UHSRUW
, KDYH H�DPL�HG �R�U FKDULW�DFFR��WV DV UHT�LUHG ��GHU VHFWLR���RI WKH &KDULWLHV �FW D�G P�H�DPL�DWLR��DV FDUULHG R�W L�DFFRUGD�FH �LWK WKH JH�HUDO 'LUHFWLR�V JLYH�E�WKH &KDULW�&RPPLVVLR�IRU 1RUWKHU�,UHOD�G ��GHU VHFWLR�������E�RI WKH &KDULWLHV �FW�7KH H�DPL�DWLR�L�FO�GHG D UHYLH�RI WKH DFFR��WL�J UHFRUGV NHSW E�WKH FKDULW� D�G D FRPSDULVR�RI WKH DFFR��WV SUHVH�WHG �LWK WKRVH UHFRUGV�,W DOVR L�FO�GHG FR�VLGHUDWLR�RI D�����V�DO LWHPV RU GLVFORV�UHV�L��WKH�DFFR��WV��D�G�VHHNL�J�H�SOD�DWLR�V�IURP��R��DV�FKDULW��WU�VWHHV�FR�FHU�L�J�D���V�FK�PDWWHUV�
0��UROH�LV�WR�VWDWH��KHWKHU�D���PDWHULDO�PDWWHUV�KDYH�FRPH�WR�P��DWWH�WLR��JLYL�J�PH�FD�VH�WR�EHOLHYH�
-
7KDW�DFFR��WL�J�UHFRUGV��HUH��RW�NHSW�L��DFFRUGD�FH��LWK�VHFWLR������RI�WKH�&RPSD�LHV��FW�����
-
7KDW�WKH�DFFR��WV�GR��RW�DFFRUG��LWK�WKRVH�DFFR��WL�J�UHFRUGV
-
7KDW WKH DFFR��WV GR �RW FRPSO��LWK WKH DFFR��WL�J UHT�LUHPH�WV RI VHFWLR����RI WKH &RPSD�LHV �FW ����D�G �LWK WKH PHWKRGV D�G SUL�FLSOHV RI WKH &KDULWLHV 6WDWHPH�W RI 5HFRPPH�GHG 3UDFWLFH DSSOLFDEOH WR FKDULWLHV SUHSDUL�J WKHLU DFFR��WV L�DFFRUGD�FH �LWK WKH )L�D�FLDO 5HSRUWL�J 6WD�GDUG DSSOLFDEOH L�WKH 8. D�G 5HS�EOLF RI ,UHOD�G
-
7KDW�WKHUH�LV�I�UWKHU�L�IRUPDWLR���HHGHG�IRU�D�SURSHU���GHUVWD�GL�J�RI�WKH�DFFR��WV�WR�EH�UHDFKHG�
)XUWKHU�L�IRUPDWLR���HHGHG�IRU�D�SURSHU�X�GHUVWD�GL���RI�WKH�DFFRX�WV
�IWHU WKH �HDU H�G WKH FKDULW�IR��G D VL�HDEOH UHVWULFWHG GR�DWLR�WKDW KDG PLVWDNH�O�EHH�L�FO�GHG L���UHVWULFWHG L�FRPH�7KH FRUUHFWLR�RI WKLV HUURU KDV UHV�OWHG L�WKH FKDULW��V ��UHVWULFWHG I��GV EHL�J L�GHILFLW E�������DW WKH �HDU H�G�7KLV PHD�V WKDW VRPH RI WKH FKDULW��V UHVWULFWHG I��GV KDYH EHH��VHG WR PHHW ��UHVWULFWHG H�SH�GLW�UH D�G KDYH �RW EHH�VSH�W L�DFFRUGD�FH �LWK UHVWULFWLR�V�)�UWKHUPRUH WKH GHILFLW R���UHVWULFWHG I��GV V�JJHVWV WKDW WKH FKDULW� PLJKW IL�G LW GLIILF�OW WR FR�WL��H RSHUDWL�J DV D JRL�J FR�FHU�� , GUD�DWWH�WLR�WR 1RWH �L�WKH DFFR��WV D�G WKH VHFWLR�KHDGL�J �5HVHUYHV 3ROLF���RL�J &R�FHU��L�WKH WU�VWHHV�D���DO UHSRUW��KLFK VHWV R�W WKH DFWLR�V EHL�J WDNH�E�WKH WU�VWHHV WR UHE�LOG ��UHVWULFWHG I��GV �D�G WKHUHIRUH UHSOH�LVK WKH PR�H�WKDW �DV VSH�W IURP UHVWULFWHG I��GV�D�G WKH GLUHFWRUV�UHDVR�V IRU FR�FO�GL�J WKDW WKH FKDULW�FD�FR�WL��H DV D JRL�J FR�FHU�V �D�G KH�FH IRU WKH �VH�RI�WKH�JRL�J�FR�FHU��EDVLV�L��WKH�SUHSDUDWLR��RI�WKHVH�IL�D�FLDO�VWDWHPH�WV��
,�GHSH�GH�W�H�DPL�HU�V�VWDWHPH�W
, KDYH FRPSOHWHG P�H�DPL�DWLR��,�FR��HFWLR��LWK IROOR�L�J WKH 'LUHFWLR�V RI WKH &KDULW�&RPPLVVLR�IRU 1RUWKHU� ,UHOD�G�
- D� ,�KDYH��R�FR�FHU�V�L��UHVSHFW�RI�WKH�PDWWHUV�����WR�����OLVWHG�DERYH E� :LWK UHVSHFW WR PDWWHU ����DOO PDWWHUV WKDW UHT�LUH GUD�L�J WR �R�U DWWH�WLR�KDYH EHH�GLVFORVHG L�P�5HSRUW �VHH VHFWLR��KHDGL�J��)�UWKHU�L�IRUPDWLR���HHGHG�IRU�D�SURSHU���GHUVWD�GL�J�RI�WKH�DFFR��WV���
�MD��5DMD�L�)&,( 6WH�DUGVKLS ��/DPE�V�3DVVDJH /R�GR���(&������
- 'DWH� 27 July 2023
3DJH��