Balliol College
Annual Report and Financial Statements for the year ended 31 July 2024
Registered Charity No. 1144032
Balliol College Year ended 31 July 2024
Contents
Report of the Governing Body ................................................................................ 1 Reference and administrative details..................................................................... 1 Structure, governance and management ................................................................. 1 Members of the Governing Body ........................................................................... 3 College Senior Staff ......................................................................................... 5 College Advisers ............................................................................................. 6 Objectives and Activities ................................................................................... 7 Plans for future periods ..................................................................................... 9 Achievements and Performance ........................................................................... 9 Governance ................................................................................................. 15 Fundraising ................................................................................................. 15 Financial and Investment Review ....................................................................... 15 Investment policy, objectives and performance ...................................................... 16 Reserves policy ............................................................................................. 17 Grant making ............................................................................................... 17 Risk management .......................................................................................... 17 Statement of accounting and reporting responsibilities ................................................ 18 Independent Auditor’s Report to the Trustees of Balliol College...................................... 19 Statement of Principal Accounting Policies ............................................................... 23 Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities .......................................................... 28 Consolidated and College Balance sheets ................................................................. 29 Consolidated Statement of Cashflows ..................................................................... 30 Notes to the Financial Statements ......................................................................... 31
Balliol College Year ended 31 July 2024
Report of the Governing Body
The Members of the Governing Body present their Annual Report for the year ended 31 July 2024 under the Charities Act 2011 together with the audited consolidated financial statements for the year.
Reference and administrative details
The Master and Scholars of Balliol College in the University of Oxford, which is known as Balliol College (“the College”), are a charitable body having that name. The College was founded in the 13[th] century and is registered with the Charity Commission for England and Wales (registered number 1144032).
The names of all Members of the Governing Body at the date of this report and of those in office during the year, together with details of the senior staff and advisers of the College, are given on pages 3 to 6.
Structure, governance and management
Governing documents
The College is governed by its Statutes originally granted in 1282, and subsequently approved by the foundation deed of 1284. In their most recent version they stand as approved by Her Majesty in Council, 11 March 2020, in accordance with the 1923 Oxford and Cambridge Act.
Governing Body
The Governing Body is constituted and regulated in accordance with the College Statutes, which are as made from time to time by order of His Majesty in Council in accordance with the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge Act 1923. The Governing Body holds to itself the responsibilities for the ongoing strategic direction of the College, for its administration and for the management of its finances and assets. It meets regularly under the chairmanship of the Master and is advised by a range of committees. The College enjoys the unique privilege of electing its own Visitor, a post currently occupied by The Right Hon Lord Reed of Allemuir.
Organisational management
The Governing Body understands the importance of being kept informed on current issues in the sector, and charity regulation and legislation form a regular part of Governing Body business. A College office of Fellow for Charity Matters is in place to facilitate this. A code on the Handling of Conflict of Interests is available to all Fellows.
The members of the Governing Body meet nine times a year. The work of developing their policies and monitoring the implementation of these is carried out by five Committees:
-
Tutorial Board meets once a term and includes all the College’s Tutorial Fellows, those with personal tutor roles in relation to undergraduates and members of the Academic Progress Committee. Tutorial Board has the power to decide many matters of academic policy but for much of this work is delegated to the Academic Committee and, for decisions about the academic progress of individual students, to an Academic Progress Committee.
-
Academic Progress Committee deals with decisions about the progress of individual students and can apply academic disciplinary measures. Its membership consists of the Master, Vice-Master (Academic), Senior Tutor, Dean and Chaplain, four Tutorial Fellows and, ex officio, the Praefectus.
-
Executive Committee deals primarily with the College’s administration and finances and meets weekly during term. Its membership consists of the Master, Vice-Master (Executive), Finance Bursar, Domestic Bursar, Senior Tutor/Academic Registrar, Praefectus, Dean and six Fellows who are not College Officers plus student representation.
1
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
-
Academic Committee concentrates on academic policy and meets weekly during term. It has an approximately equal number of College Officers and non-officers as its membership. Full Academic Committee, which meets approximately once a term, includes student representation.
-
Remuneration Committee, with an external chair and four other external members, alongside four internal members including the Master and Finance Bursar, meets termly in order to give oversight and counsel to the College’s Governing Body with respect to the pay and benefits of its trustees and officers.
Most other committees in College are sub-committees of either the Academic Committee or Executive Committee and are devoted to specific areas of College activity, such as Library, Sports and Development. There are however three important exceptions, which them report direct to meetings of the Governing Body:
-
The Chapel and Patronage Committee overseas the College Chapel and the several ecclesiastical livings for which the College retains a historic responsibility.
-
The Nominating Committee makes recommendations to College Meeting on who are to be College Officers and what the membership of committees should be.
-
The Investments Committee is responsible for the governance and management of the College’s investments, making recommendation to the Governing Body for approval. It consists of the Master and Finance Bursar (ex officio), three current Fellows and six external members.
The day-to-day running of the College is overseen by the Master. Academic matters are delegated primarily to the Senior Tutor/Academic Registrar, financial and investment matters to the Finance Bursar and domestic and estates matters to the Domestic Bursar.
Recruitment and training of Members of the Governing Body
New Members of the Governing Body (Trustees) are recruited as Fellows, and are inducted into the workings of the College according to the nature of their Fellowship and by attending Governing Body meetings. The duties and responsibilities of Trustees are explained fully to incumbent Fellows and form part of the induction process.
Remuneration of Members of the Governing Body and College Officers
Members of the Governing Body are primarily teaching and research employees of the College or University and receive no remuneration or benefits from their trusteeship of the College. There are also four trustees who work on management and fundraising, the Master, Senior Tutor/Academic Registrar, Finance Bursar and Development Director.
Trustees that are also employees of the College receive remuneration for their work as employees of the College which is set based on the advice of the College’s Remuneration Committee.
Group structure and relationships
The College has one wholly owned non-charitable subsidiary, Balliol College Developments Limited, which is a company providing building contractor, conference and other event services on College premises. The annual profits of Balliol College Developments Limited are donated to the College under the Gift Aid Scheme.
The College is part of the collegiate University of Oxford. Material interdependencies between the University and the College arise as a consequence of this relationship.
2
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Members of the Governing Body
The Master and Fellows of the College are the Members of the Governing Body and are the College’s Trustees under charity law. The members of the Governing Body who served in office during the year or subsequently are detailed below.
The activities of the Governing Body are carried out through the five main committees outlined above. The membership of these committees (as at 31 July 2024) is shown below:
-
(1) Tutorial Board
-
(2) Academic Progress Committee
-
(3) Executive Committee
-
(4) Academic Committee
-
(5) Remuneration Committee
Dame Helen Ghosh, Master (1,2,3,4,5)
Prof Miguel Ballester Professor of Economics, Lord Thomson of Fleet Fellow and Tutor in Economics (1,4)
Prof William Barford Professor of Theoretical Chemistry, Fellow and Tutor in Physical Chemistry (1,2,5)
Prof James Belich (demitted 17th June 2024) Beit Professor Commonwealth and Imperial History and Professorial Fellow
Dr Alexander Bown Associate Professor, Fellow and Tutor in Ancient Philosophy (1)
Dr Daniel Butt Associate Professor, Robert Maxwell Fellow and Tutor in Political Theory (1)
Prof Coralia Cartis Professor of Numerical Optimisation and Fellow and Tutor in Mathematics (1,4)
Dr Adam Caulton Associate Professor, Clarendon University Lecturer, Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy, and Tutor for Graduate Admissions (1,4)
Dr Vincent Cheval (appointed 6th October 2023) Associate Professor and Tutorial Fellow in Computer Science (1)
Prof Robin Choudhury Professor of Cardiovascular Medicine and Senior Research Fellow in Biomedical Sciences
Prof Martin Conway Professor of Contemporary European History, MacLellan-Warburg Fellow and Tutor in History, and Welfare Fellow (1)
Prof Neta Crawford Montague Burton Professor of International Relations and Professorial Fellow
Prof Kate Crosby Numata Professor of Buddhist Studies and Professorial Fellow
Dr Katrina Davis Associate Professor, Fellow and Tutor in Zoology (1)
Dr Hasan Dindjer Associate Professor, Blanesburgh Fellow and Tutor in Law (1,4)
Prof Soumitra Dutta Dean of Saïd Business School and Professorial Fellow
Prof Edith Elkind (demitted 17th June 2024) Professor of Computing Science and Research Fellow in Computational Game Theory (3)
Prof David Enoch (appointed 6th October 2023) Professor of Philosophy of Law, Pauline and Max Gordon Fellow and Professorial Fellow (2)
Mr James Forder Andrew Graham Fellow and Tutor in Political Economy, and Dean (1,3)
3
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Dr Dorian Gangloff (demitted 4th December 2023) Associate Professor of Engineering Science and Royal Society University Research Fellow, Fellow and Tutor in Engineering Science (1)
Prof John-Paul Ghobrial Professor of Modern and Global History, Lucas Fellow and Tutor in History (1,4)
Prof Mike Giles (appointed 12th January 2024) Professor of Numerical Analysis and Professorial Fellow Dr Helen Gittos Associate Professor, Colyer-Fergusson Fellow and Tutor in Early Medieval History (1,3) Prof Sir Charles Godfray Director of the Oxford Martin School and Professorial Fellow
Prof Ian Goldin Professor of Globalisation and Development and Senior Research Fellow
Prof Freddie Hamdy Nuffield Professor of Surgery and Professorial Fellow
Dr Sudhir Hazareesingh CUF Lecturer in Politics, Coolidge Fellow and Tutorial Fellow in Politics, and Senior Fellow (1)
Prof Philip Howard Professor of Internet Studies and Professorial Fellow
Dr Alexander Kaiserman Associate Professor, Fairfax Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy (1,2)
Dr Adrian Kelly Associate Professor, Clarendon University Lecturer, Fellow and Tutor in Ancient Greek Language and Literature (1,4)
Revd Canon Bruce Kinsey (demitted 30th September 2023) Chaplain
Dr Elizabeth Kiss Professorial Fellow and Warden of Rhodes House
Prof James Kwan Associate Professor and Tutorial Fellow in Engineering Science (1)
Dr Grant Lamond Associate Professor, Frankfurter Fellow and Tutor in Law (1,2)
Dr Matthew Langton Associate Professor of Inorganic Chemistry and Royal Society University Research Fellow, Fellow and Tutor in Inorganic Chemistry (1)
Prof Elena Lombardi Professor of Italian Literature, Paget Toynbee Lecturer in Italian Medieval Studies, Fellow and Tutor in Italian, and Praefectus of Holywell Manor (1,3)
Prof Jason Lotay Professor of Pure Mathematics and Tutorial Fellow in Mathematics (1,3)
Prof David Lucas Professor of Physics, Fellow and Tutor in Physics (1,5)
Prof Andre Lukas Professor of Physics, Fellow and Tutor in Theoretical Physics (1,2)
Prof Jim Mallinson (appointed 6th October 2023) Boden Professor of Sanskrit and Professorial Fellow (3)
Prof Sophie Marnette Professor of Medieval French Studies, Dervorguilla Fellow and Tutor in French (1)
Prof Tom Melham Professor of Computer Science and Fellow and Tutor in Computation (1)
Dr Derek Moulton Associate Professor, Fellow and Tutor in Mathematics (1)
Prof Thomas Noe Ernest Butten Professor of Management Studies and Professorial Fellow (1)
Mr Richard Norman Development Director
Prof Dominic O’Brien Professor of Engineering Science and Senior Research Fellow in Engineering (1,3)
Prof Dermot O’Hare Professor of Chemistry, Senior Research Fellow in Chemistry and SCG Fellow (1,4) Mr Richard Ovenden Bodley’s Librarian and Professorial Fellow
Dr Sandra Paoli Research Fellow in Romance Linguistics
4
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Prof Seamus Perry Professor of English Literature, Massey Fellow, Tutor in English, Vice-Master (Executive), Fellow Librarian and Fellow for Charity Matters (1,2,3)
Prof Armin Reichold Professor of Physics, Fellow and Tutor in Physics (1)
Dr Matthew Robinson Associate Professor, Fairfax Fellow and Tutor in Latin Literature (1)
Prof Sebastian Shimeld Professor of Evolutionary Developmental Biology, Julian Huxley Fellow and Tutor in Zoology, and Vice-Master (Academic) (1,2,4,5)
Dr Simon Skinner Associate Professor, Keen Fellow and Tutor in History (1,2)
Dr Jennifer Sliwka (appointed 6th October 2023) Keeper of Western Art, Garlick Fellow and Professorial Fellow
Prof Adam Smyth Professor of English Literature and the History of the Book, Clarendon University Lecturer, A.C. Bradley-J.C. Maxwell Fellow and Tutor in English Literature (1)
Prof Tim Soutphommasane Chief Diversity Officer, Professor of Practice in Human Rights and Political Theory, and Senior Research Fellow
Prof Jin-Chong Tan Professor of Engineering Science (Nanoscale Engineering), Fellow and Tutor in Engineering Science (1,4)
Prof John Tasioulas Professor of Ethics and Legal Philosophy, Senior Research Fellow, and Director of the Institute for Ethics in AI
Prof Rosalind Thomas Professor of Greek History, Dyson-Macgregor Fellow, Jowett Lecturer and Tutor in Ancient History (1)
Mrs Amanda Tilley Finance Bursar (3,5)
Prof Nick Trefethen (demitted 17th June 2024) Professor of Numerical Analysis and Professorial Fellow (3)
Dr Nicola Trott Senior Tutor and Academic Registrar, and Tutor for Graduates (1,2,3,4)
Dr Lisa Walker Fellow in Medical Sciences, and Tutor for Undergraduate Admissions (1,4)
Prof David Wark Professor of Experimental Particle Physics and Senior Research Fellow
Prof Manuela Zaccolo Professor of Cell Biology, Fellow and Tutor in Biomedical Sciences (1,3)
College Senior Staff
The senior staff of the College to whom day to day management is delegated are as follows: Dr Nicola Trott Senior Tutor / Academic Registrar
Mrs Amanda Tilley Finance Bursar
Mrs Keeley Mortimer Interim Domestic Bursar (from 20[th] June 2023 to 5[th] November 2023)
Mrs Jennifer Smith Domestic Bursar (from 6[th] November 2023)
5
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
College Advisers
Investment managers
Commonfund Capital, Inc, 15 Old Danbury Road, Wilton, CT 06897, USA OU Endowment Management, 27 Park End Street, Oxford OX1 1HU
Oxford Investment Partners, Towers Watson Ltd, Watson House, London Road, Reigate, Surrey RH2 9PQ Partners Capital LLP, 5[th] Floor, 5 Young Street, London, W8 5EH
Ruffer LLP, 80 Victoria Street, London. SW1E 5JL
Savills Investment Management, 33 Margaret Street, London, W1G 0JD
Vanguard Asset Management Ltd, 4[th] Floor, The Walbrook Building, 25 Walbrook, London, EC4N 8AF
Independent auditors
Crowe UK LLP, 5[th] Floor, R+Building, 2 Blagrave Street, Reading, RG1 1AZ
Bankers
HSBC Bank Plc, Hanborough House, Wallbrook Court, 5 North Hinksey Lane, Oxford. OX2 0QS
Solicitors
Knights plc, Midland House, West Way, Botley, Oxford, OX2 0PH
College address
Balliol College, Broad Street, Oxford, OX1 3BJ
Website
www.balliol.ox.ac.uk
6
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Objectives and Activities
Charitable objects and aims
The College’s objects are to advance education, religion, learning and research and to be a college within the University of Oxford.
The Governing Body has considered the Charity Commission’s guidance on public benefit and in keeping with its objects, the College’s aims for the public benefit are:
-
To provide for members of the University of Oxford a college wherein they may participate in the educational facilities offered by, and study for degrees in, the University of Oxford.
-
To do all such other things as are incidental or conducive to advancing education, learning and research in Oxford or elsewhere.
-
The aims set for the College’s subsidiary are to help finance the achievement of the College’s aims as above.
Activities and objectives of the College
The College exists to advance education at both undergraduate and graduate levels; to facilitate and to encourage scholarship and research at the very highest levels; to promote excellence in learning; to maintain a chapel and chaplaincy, and to serve as patron to its numerous livings.
Public benefit
The College remains committed to the aim of providing public benefit in accordance with its Objects, and has continued to conduct its affairs during the year to 31 July 2024 in furtherance of these aims. Examples of this are described below.
The College is a mixed College, providing higher education to undergraduates and postgraduates. Places are available based on purely on academic merit and financial support is available to students to assist them with their costs whilst at College. This includes financial assistance based on need, as well as a range of grants to cover academic and extra-curricular expenses, such as academic project grants, thesis binding expenses, sports equipment and travel grants. It spent £1.9m on grants (see note 8) in the year, including contribution to the Oxford Bursary scheme and £1.7m on a range of graduate scholarships.
The College makes many of its talks and lectures available to the public as online lectures and operates an outreach programme which works with schools to help encourage and support able student to apply to Oxford University.
The College’s archive centre in St Cross Road is available for enquiries from the public. Nearly 450 enquiries were received and over 130 research visits took place this year. In addition, nearly 1,000 people attended exhibitions held during the year, including ‘Going up to Balliol: Mountaineering at the College’.
Education and learning
The College draws on its endowments and other income to provide undergraduate education in a wide range of subjects, within the context of the University of Oxford, to students recruited to the College on the basis of their academic record and promise. Balliol employs Tutors and Lecturers to teach and advise them; administrative and welfare staff to support them; and offers an array of academic and other educational facilities, including a Library, musical and theatrical spaces, diverse sporting facilities, and multiple environments for recreation, reflection, self-improvement, and debate. Graduate students have access to the same College facilities and services.
The oldest college in continuous existence on the same site in the University of Oxford, Balliol occupies a beautiful and historic site in the middle of the city with buildings dating from the fifteenth century. The College is normally open daily to the public, with access to the grounds and (as practicable) to the main public spaces.
7
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Numerous Balliol events are also open to the public, including services in Chapel, occasional lectures and talks, and, normally every other Sunday evening during term a concert in the College Hall, continuing a tradition of Balliol concerts that began in 1885. Balliol has long sought to contribute to the wider educational world. It appoints (normally from among its Fellowship) Trustees to Ludlow College; Trustees to the Keith Rae Trust; Trustees to the Balliol Society (which supports the College’s charitable activities); Trustees to the Balliol College Educational Trust; and Trustees to the Chalet Trust.
Research
The College materially supports the research of its academic staff by a programme of sabbatical leave from tutorial duties, and by making available reasonable funds to support academic pursuits, and to subsidise research and publication (Statutes IX.2). The Balliol Interdisciplinary Institute (“BII”) cultivates and supports interdisciplinary research, straddling the humanities, the social sciences, and the physical and medical sciences. The Institute gives senior members and graduate students the opportunity to propose and develop advanced research that requires contributions from more than one discipline. The BII supports both gestational projects and more fully fledged proposals. Pioneering interdisciplinary research sometimes requires a period of open-ended exploration and time to build strong teams. By helping gestational projects, the BII can facilitate experimental freedom with low risk, or it can boost more developed projects that are still small in scale or require only modest resources.
At its annex in Holywell Manor, the College offers an academically stimulating home to a large and international community of graduate research students, admitted to their courses from a distinguished application by the University of Oxford, and a large number of students on taught graduate courses. Graduate supervision is frequently undertaken by Fellows of the College. Holywell Manor offers a popular space for recreation, intellectual exchange, and debate.
The work of Balliol research students is additionally supported by a generous programme of graduate scholarships, many established by endowment, and the College makes numerous additional financial awards on the basis of unexpected need, overseen by its Student Finance Committee. The College contributes to the research activity of the University by (for example) hosting the Oxford Internet Institute in 1 St Giles, and by administering funds which support particular areas of study, such as the Numata Fund which supports Buddhist studies in Oxford and the Skynner Fund which supports astrophysics.
The College has large and distinguished research collections under its curatorship, which it is pleased to make as fully available as possible. Its extensive collections of medieval and modern literary, political, and scientific papers are cared for in its specially constructed Historic Collections Centre at St Cross, Holywell. The Centre also houses the College’s extensive Archives, a valuable source for historians of the nation as well as of Balliol and the University of Oxford. The College also cares for numerous paintings, especially portraits of former members; some pieces of silver, also mostly commemorative; and various objets d’art. The College has published several catalogues of its diverse holdings, in print and latterly on-line, and cataloguing continues. Bona fide researchers, including interested members of the public, are welcome to consult material in the College’s care by appointment. The College has a liberal policy of lending items to exhibitions upon request.
Numerous scholarly projects have come to fruition with the College’s ready collaboration, including (among others) editions of several medieval texts, editions of the poets Browning, Arnold, Clough, and Hopkins, and many other books and articles that demonstrate Balliol’s ambitions to facilitate and extend scholarship and learning.
Religion
The College maintains a Chaplaincy by Statute (VII.10) and the Chapel offers services throughout the academic term which are open to the public. The College retains its position as Patron of twenty livings across England, a role which it assumes with proper diligence and care, keeping in close and supportive contact with its parishes, welcoming their representatives periodically to the College, and offering assistance in their activities as requested.
8
Balliol College Year ended 31 July 2024
Plans for future periods
The core elements of the College’s future plans are as follows;
-
To continue its principal activity to provide, promote and engage in education, learning and research.
-
To continue those activities which support the public benefit aims.
-
To improve the quality of all its provisions made by the College to its students, Fellows and others.
-
To conduct development activities in order to secure the long-term future of the College.
Achievements and Performance
Selected highlights of the 2023/2024 year:
It is not often that Balliol receives royalty. The journey to Oxford of the Emperor and Empress of Japan at the end of the imperial couple’s State Visit to the UK, and in particular the return on 28 June 2024 of Empress Masako to her
alma mater , of which she is an Honorary Fellow, was an occasion of great pride and pleasure. Their Majesties were welcomed to Balliol by the Master and the Chancellor and, in the tour which followed, the Empress was able to meet again her former supervisor, Sir Adam Roberts, and the then Praefectus of the Graduate Centre at Holywell Manor, Professor Denis Noble (both now Emeritus Fellows), with Sir Adam’s office in the Brackenbury Quad and the Manor itself on Their Majesties’ itinerary. The University’s conferral on Empress Masako of an
honorary degree at a ceremony presided over by Lord Patten was a highlight of a term that was otherwise pre-occupied with the many events taking place across the collegiate University to mark his retirement, after twenty-one years, as Chancellor. Published online, Lord Patten’s letter to the Vice-Chancellor demonstrates to the full that, in him, the University found a uniquely eloquent champion. The College adds its tribute of thanks for his tireless service, and looks forward to continuing to welcome him back as an alumnus and Honorary Fellow.
Not long before the imperial visit, the College celebrated the completion of a major refurbishment. On 17 June, the Gillis Lecture Theatre and Warburg Music Suite were formally opened in the presence of three of the benefactors who enabled the project and in memory of a fourth. The design also incorporates a new teaching space and music practice rooms with additional sound-proofing - though on this occasion guests were audibly entertained by a student at the baby-grand in the Music Suite and treated to a display of archival material put together by Library staff. The modern and flexible areas created by these transformational gifts are now in constant and varied use. Indeed, the Gillis Lecture Theatre is shortly to be the venue for the Fellowship to hold initial discussions around potential future building projects for the College.
9
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Another highlight of the College’s year has been the establishment of the Balliol Sanctuary Fund. Launched in November 2023, the Fund recognises a long tradition of the College, with the active support or initiation of a new generation of Fellows, staff, students and alumni. The College is grateful to the many Old Members who have contributed to enable those who for reasons of conflict or persecution would otherwise have had little or no access to higher education to find refuge and a place of study at Balliol.
More light-hearted initiatives included a collective – one hesitates to say corporate – identity for the hearteningly large number of runners among Balliol staff, students, and Fellows, who for the first time joined forces to enter as an official team in the annual Town and Gown 10k, this year held on an oppressively hot Sunday 12 May. An unlikely favourite of this newly cross-college sporting life proved to be the highly competitive egg-and-spoon race held in the Brackenbury Quad on 20 March. In the race of fingers on buzzers, meanwhile, a very fine University Challenge team was mustered but had the misfortune of meeting in the first round the eventual champions of 2024. Traditional student team sports and Cuppers contests produced some excellent performances across the year: Balliol basketball and squash players overcame runners-up positions in previous competitions to earn Cuppers trophies, and in reaching the semifinals the rugby squad came the closest to winning Cuppers since the Balliol victory of 1933. Their last match of the season gained the men’s football team promotion to Division 1, the netball team maintained its First Division position, and the Women’s 1st VIII won blades for the second consecutive year and the W1 crew’s highest river position in over a decade.
Creatives also found ways to shine. A Holywell Manor Photography Prize was inaugurated, to the theme of ‘Landscapes of Learning’. A paperless student publication, Erasmus, was launched. The annual ritual of ghost stories in the library – with specially selected readings and exhibits – took place in November 2023. In Hilary Term 2024, the College once again hosted as Artist in Residence Honorary Fellow and former National Poet of Wales, Gwyneth Lewis, who added to her own programme for Balliol students a collaboration with the current Professor of Poetry, A.E. Stallings. In August 2023, a five-day workshop on teaching about the transatlantic slave-trade brought US and UK educators to Balliol as part of a three-year teachers’ programme organised by Balliol Library in collaboration with the Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphia, and spinning out of its own imaginative Slavery in the Age of Revolution exhibition.
The Library’s main exhibitions of this year, offered as usual in the Historic Collections Centre at St Cross Church, and aided by its beautiful new display cases, were ‘‘Messing About with Manuscripts’: R.A.B. Mynors and Balliol’s Medieval Library’ and ‘Going Up to Balliol: Mountaineering at the College’. Mynors’ ‘messing’ would now be called ‘material culture’ or ‘history of the book’, and it lives on in the research interests of several current Fellows and Tutors. There is a connection between the two exhibitions, as well, because it was to Mynors that Balliol Dean and History Tutor FF Urquhart bequeathed the Chalet des Anglais in the French Alps where student reading and walking parties still take place each summer. Accompanied by a series of talks, the latter exhibition (‘Going Up…’) gave a fascinating account of the close and significant ties Balliol people have to the whole history of alpinism. The ties continue to this day: the Librarian who curated the exhibition is a keen mountaineer and I was pleased to catch sight of one of the sixteen students lucky enough to be travelling to North America or Asia as William Westerman Pathfinders this year taking his climbing shoes with him to Colorado.
If aiming high is the common pursuit, then Balliol mountaineering is not so far removed from Balliol outreach. Activity in this area takes a long time to feed through to results, but we now have enough years of data to produce useful analysis of the impact our work in schools – and by extension the generous donations that support it – is having. A report in February 2024 showed that in the 2023 undergraduate admissions round, 90 students who attended Balliol access events or programmes received offers from Oxford University, 15 of them from Balliol and 75 from other colleges; and that more than two-thirds of state school applicants to Balliol in that admissions round came from schools that received Balliol outreach support during the 2022/2023 academic year. The range and scale of output from one small department (in HR terms, the David Freeman Outreach Officer, a post named for another benefaction, and her Assistant) is remarkable – and an example of ‘whole college’ co-operation and engagement, involving not just Tutors and Lecturers but a large number of students, including graduate teachers, as well as staff from across the College.
10
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Outreach can and does take many forms, all the way from formally Building Bridges with primary school children in partnership with the Ashmolean, to receiving informally a visit from university-age students with a connection to the College via an alumnus and a shared faith and social practice.
For anyone in search of a genuine slice of current student life, however, the JCR takeover of the College’s Instagram account to showcase Balliol to prospective applicants gives a whiff of the real.
Reaching out also means bringing people in. This year for various reasons the College hosted not, as is customary, one, but no fewer than three George
Eastman Visiting Professors, in successive terms. In a further break with tradition, the first Eastman was Anna Deveare Smith, of West Wing fame, who came as a practitioner-writer-producer for stage and screen and ran theatre workshops with student playwrights. Another unconventional visit was that of Steven Freilich, whose career in research and business leadership at DuPont led, as a result of SCG Fellow Dermot O’Hare’s industrial partnerships, to an Oliver Smithies Visiting Fellowship. In combination with academic appointments, these riffs on the College’s visiting programme made for an especially vibrant set of talks and interactions.
One such interaction saw visitors – among them this year’s Winant Visting Professor of American Government, Jason Casellas, who spoke about US Latino Republican elections – giving online talks as part of the monthly on-going series organised by the Development Office. Available to all alumni as well as current members, this has become a mainstay of the academic calendar and one that we are glad to know is enjoyed by the Balliol community-at-large.
Annual headline events, the Dawkins Prize Lecture and Omar Azfar Lecture, were delivered to live audiences in Trinity Term 2024. In addition, a one-off speaking event took place in response to the widespread concern arising from the attack on Israel by Hamas and the subsequent war in Gaza, leading in turn to protests and polarization of views on campuses in various parts of the world, Oxford included. The College’s internal discussions enabled contrasting student representations to be heard at its Executive Committee; and on 28 May two Balliol Professorial Fellows, David Enoch (Professor of Philosophy of Law) and Neta Crawford (Professor of International Relations) made presentations from differing perspectives and led a considered debate on some of the core issues as they were understood at that time. Making space for dialogue that is at once meaningful and respectful, inclusive and informed, can be a vital if demanding function of a university.
11
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
The 2023/2024 academic year events archive shows a rich variety of cultural activity, from the Balliol Literary Society’s reading of Stoppard’s Arcadia , to the soirée with Honorary Fellow Amit Chaudhuri in conversation about his New and Selected Poems with Fellow and Tutor in English Seamus Perry, to the lunches hosted by the Chaplain for students to practice ‘close reading’ with the Artist in Residence or explore ‘Ways of Seeing’ some of the masterpieces of European painting, to the free and public Balliol Musical Society Concerts held – in timehonoured fashion – fortnightly in term. More explicitly directed at the wellbeing of
current members, in particular of students, is an evolving cycle of activity created by the Welfare Lead with the Student Support Officer, and involving many other members of staff, which ranges from regular welfare newsletters, to ‘wellbeing walks’, ‘feel good singing’ sessions, drop-ins for students living off-site, floral and bouquet-making workshops, pop-ups showcasing the library’s wellbeing collections, and opt-in exercise classes for both mind and body. This ‘something for everyone’ approach sits alongside the formal support structures of welfare, counselling and health services.
Awards and achievements of current members
Neta Crawford, Andrew Hurrell’s successor as Montague Burton Professor of International Relations, won accolades for her book on the Pentagon’s carbon footprint and contribution to climate change, notably an Anti-Censorship Award and the Grawemeyer Award for Ideas Improving World Order. Recognition, in the modern academy, is highly diversified and, in the humanities, may signal support for diversity itself: in October 2023 Adrian Kelly’s co-edited Cambridge Companion to Sappho was placed by Choice magazine among its Outstanding Academic Titles 2022: LGBTQ+ Pride. Two further instances of the plurality of, and of awards for, humanities research were the Ann Moss Early Career Essay Prize given to College Lecturer Maria Czepiel by The Society for Neo-Latin Studies for her work on Jewish scholarship in an early modern Spanish writer; and the Colin Franklin Prize for Book Collecting awarded to graduate student Hermán Luis Chávez for their submission on how discovering a piano score led to researching, performing, and collecting little known 20th-century Bolivian Art Music. Still in the performance space, graduate composer (and Junior Dean) Carol Jones saw premiere two of her own pieces of music, one of them commissioned to sit alongside Mahler, no less. Acclaim for classical academic scholarship persists, of course: Linda Eggert, Early Career Fellow in Philosophy, won the 2023 Frank Chapman Sharp Memorial Prize recognizing the best submission of unpublished work on the philosophy of war and peace, awarded by the American Philosophical Association for her ‘Duties to Rescue and Permissions to Harm’. Linda was also named as AI2050 Early Career Fellow by Schmidt Sciences. This appointment reflects the connection she has to Oxford’s Institute for Ethics in AI, the Director of which, John Tasioulas, an alumnus and now Senior Research Fellow at Balliol, is a Senior Fellow in the AI2050 programme. Professor Tasioulas was also appointed to an Advisory Committee on AI recently established by the Greek government and, together with Stanford’s Josiah Ober, George Eastman Visiting Professor in Trinity Term 2024, led the Lyceum Project held in Athens in June 2024, the White Paper for which presents Aristotle’s ethics as the best framework for addressing the challenges and opportunities posed by AI.
12
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
In science, markers of esteem are often straightforwardly measured by research income. Engineering Tutor Jin-Chong Tan gained a highly competitive ERC Advanced Grant for development of nanoenergy conversion technology. Oxford has also been at the forefront of the UK government’s high-stakes investment in quantum science, and in July 2024 it was announced that the University would lead the Quantum Computing Hub (QC13), with Dominic O’Brien (formerly Tutor and now Senior Research Fellow in Engineering) as its Director. Also in quantum, on the experimental atomic Physics side, Raghavendra Srinivas, Early Career Fellow and collaborator with Fellow and Tutor David Lucas in the field of iontrapping, won the Optica Foundation’s Hänsch Prize in Quantum Optics. Alongside the science of the supersmall, another crucial endeavour is in the advancement of green energy, the circular economy, and sustainable materials, for which Dermot O’Hare, Director of the SCG Chemicals Co-Oxford Centre of Excellence for Chemistry was awarded the Royal Society of Chemistry’s John B Goodenough Prize, named for the Nobel Laureate and the Statutory Professor of Inorganic Chemistry when Dermot was just starting out as an undergraduate at Oxford – an apt illustration of a virtuous circle, if not a circular economy. The interest the UK government takes in science may have been sharpened by Brexit, but STEM for Britain, a poster competition for early-stage researchers which is held in the Houses of Parliament, has been organised by the Parliamentary & Scientific Committee annually since 1977. The 2024 competition saw Balliol graduate Katherine Benjamin take silver in the Mathematical Sciences category.
Awards and achievements of alumni and former Fellows
Starting with the academies, it was a pleasure to learn in May 2024 that alumnus and former Junior Research Fellow Patrick Unwin had been elected a Fellow of the Royal Society and, in July, that four alumni, David Gellner, Daniel Harbour, James Montgomery and Adrian Moore, had been elected Fellows of the British Academy. In September 2023, the Royal Society announced that Hagan Bayley FRS, alumnus and Honorary Fellow, had been awarded its Buchanan Medal, celebrating ‘distinguished contributions to the biomedical sciences’, for ‘founding Oxford Nanopore Technology, the highly successful biotech company’. The abstruse outer reaches of mathematics were explored by alumnus Jared Lichtman, who set a new world record for prime numbers, in the process going beyond the long-standing Riemann Hypothesis relating to their distribution. In another computational universe entirely, alumnus Andrei Constantinescu co-authored the entry winning the Best Paper Award at the Web and Internet Economics 19th International Conference, WINE 2023, in Shanghai, which pinpointed how the problem of making ‘stable dinner party seating arrangements’ while incorporating guest preferences as to table plans may be solved.
One of the biggest, and best funded, prizes in scholarship, the Wolfson History Prize, this year went to an alumna, Halik Kochanski, for her book Resistance: The Underground War in Europe, 1939–1945 . The Balliol connections to the 2023 Wolfson Prize do not end there: as an undergraduate historian, Halik was taught by Maurice Keen, an erstwhile winner of the Prize; last year’s winner, Sudhir Hazareesingh, Fellow and Tutor in Politics, was on the panel of judges which made the most recent award; and also on the shortlist was a landmark book by Professorial Fellow (and Beit Professor of Global and Imperial History) James Belich, The World the Plague Made: The Black Death and the Rise of Europe .
Several honours to Old Members were in medical fields – two in the United States, where Robert Montgomery was awarded the Excellence in Transplantation Award by the National Kidney Foundation, and Norman Daniels received the Hastings Center’s 2023 Bioethics Founders’ Award for his ‘pioneering work that has addressed justice in health care’.
13
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Back in the UK, recent graduate Yusuf Ben-Tarifite, who founded ‘The Aspiring Medics’, a platform to help students from diverse backgrounds pursue careers in medicine, won both a 2023 Diana Award and, in 2024, its 25th anniversary Legacy Award, these having been set up in memory of the late Princess of Wales to recognise young people who create positive social change.
Public good and public service are never far from the Balliol mindset. In November 2023, the appointment was announced of Alison Young, former Fellow and Tutor in Law, as the next Law Commissioner
for Public Law and the Law in Wales. In Europe, Matthew Nimetz received the first Prespa Peace Prize, named for the 2018 Agreement he largely facilitated to end a long-standing naming dispute between two neighbouring countries. In the US, alumna Devaki Raj brought her expertise in AI and start-ups to the Senate Homeland Security hearing on Governing AI Through Acquisition and Procurement. And in London, but leaning to the Far East, alumna Lindy Cameron was appointed British High Commissioner to the Republic of India.
Attitudes will differ as to the result, but Balliol is proud to acknowledge all those alumni who won seats (four by re-election, three as newly elected MPs) and, in three cases, ministerial office, in the recent UK general election.
Achievements of other kinds are almost certainly under-represented, so it was especially pleasing to hear from Derek Wax, its Executive Producer, that ‘The Sixth Commandment’, a distinctive offering in the true crime genre that has gained popularity lately, had garnered Best Limited Series at both the BAFTA and RTS awards this year.
Honours
The King’s Honours for 2024, the second of his reign, were conferred on a number of alumni and current or former Fellows of Balliol. New Years Honours went to Colin Liddell (MBE, for services to theatre and the arts in Scotland), Calypso Nash (MBE, for services to British foreign policy), Professor Richard Templer (OBE, for services to climate innovation), and former Fellow and Domestic Bursar, Carl Woodall (OBE, for services to Parliament); while Birthday Honours 2024 went to Ruth Sloan (OBE, for services to Peace and Reconciliation in Northern Ireland) and Matthew Westerman (CBE, for services to Museums and to Cultural Heritage), and also to Professorial Fellow Freddie Hamdy (CBE, for services to Surgical and Cancer Sciences), who in accepting the honour paid tribute to ‘wonderful colleagues’ and expressed the hope that it would inspire the next generation ‘to not just reach what they perceive they can, but what they think they cannot’.
Two further honours were accorded to alumni, a life peerage, in the Resignation Honours of December 2023, received by Jon Moynihan (Foundation Fellow), and one of the 2023 Queen’s Anniversary Prizes for Higher and Further Education (which were inaugurated in 1994 to commemorate the 40th year in the reign of her late Majesty, Elizabeth II, and uniquely for such awards are part of the British honours system), received by Professor Paul Newman CBE, in February 2024, on behalf of the Oxford Robotics Institute.
14
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
In Memoriam
The College was saddened to learn of several deaths among its former Fellows. The Governing Body stood in memory of two George Eastman Visiting Professors, historian Natalie Zemon Davis, the first woman to hold the role, and economist and Nobel Laureate Robert Solow. The College also had notice that distinguished astronomer Brian Warner, former Henry Skynner Junior Research Fellow, had died. In conjunction with the Mathematical Institute, it again mourned the early loss, and celebrated the extraordinary life and influence, of former Fellow and Lecturer Vicky Neale, at a memorial held on 11 November 2023 in the presence of family, friends and colleagues from far and wide. And on 16 March 2024, a celebration took place in Balliol Hall of the life of Bill Newton-Smith (1943−2023), who among his many other illustrious roles was alumnus, Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy, Praefectus of Holywell Manor, and Emeritus Fellow of the College.
Governance
As a registered charity, the College is regulated by the Charity Commission. The Chair of the Commission some time ago wrote to all Oxford colleges, initially via the Conference of Colleges, seeking insight into their governance practices. In light of these communications, a small working group of Trustees has reviewed Balliol’s own practices and, with reference to the Charity Governance Code, made some recommendations for change while affirming our fundamental structures of academic self-government. It has been a useful exercise and the College will carry on implementing decisions as agreed by the Governing Body in the course of next academic year.
Fundraising
Donations and legacies received in the year amounted to £3.4m (2023: £7.6m) given by 2,150 donors (2023: 2,114) of whom the vast majority were past or present Balliol members. Selected highlights of the 2023/2024 year (p. 10) records a number of highlights made possible thanks to the generosity of benefactors.
The College’s approach to fundraising is in accordance with its charitable objectives. It employs staff on permanent and temporary contracts to build and deepen relationships with prospective donors and subsequently to solicit donations. No professional third-party agencies were employed to directly solicit donations. Through regular staff training, including with current students who participate in telephone fundraising campaigns as temporary employees, the College ensures it protects vulnerable people and others from unreasonable intrusion, persistent approaches or undue pressure to give, in the course of or in connection with fundraising for the charity.
The College adheres to the Fundraising Regulator's Code of Fundraising Practice (as amended) and has adopted and published policies on matters including gift acceptance; fundraising from and working with vulnerable people; and data protection. These policies are reviewed annually by the College’s Development Committee, which is chaired by the Master and meets termly to govern fundraising practice, including the oversight of formal complaints of which none were received this year (2023: none).
Financial and Investment Review
The financial year to 31 July 2024 was the second full year of normal activity after the coronavirus pandemic, but the year included continuing cost inflation pressures, whilst income streams did not benefit from inflation to the same extent. The College’s financial strategy is based on achieving a surplus percentage of income before depreciation, interest and endowment donations and including the total return allocated to income (endowment return available for spending), which was achieved in 2023/24. The College does not make a profit from its teaching and research activities and is financially reliant on its commercial conference activities, investment income and donations.
Overall, income has fallen 10% because of a significant endowment donation of £5m received in 2023. Excluding donations, which naturally vary year to year, income has increased by 11%. Fee income increased by 9% to £4.3m reflecting an inflationary increase in the level of unregulated fees (Home undergraduate fee levels are set by central Government and remain unchanged). Student and other residential income has
15
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
increased by 14% which reflects an increase in the number of students dining in College and an inflationary increase in student rents, set at below the rate of increases in the private student rental market. Since the completion of the student accommodation at the Master’s Field (Dervorguilla site) the College is able to offer all its undergraduates rooms throughout the duration of their course and houses around 65% of its graduates.
Other income relates to grants towards the work of the International Panel on the Information Environment, co-founded and chaired by Professor Philip Howard, and a grant to enable the College to commission heat decarbonisation plan plus income from the College Nursery.
The investment portfolio generated £3.3m (2023: £3.0m) of investment income in the year. The College operates a total return policy to its investments to maximise the overall return available to the College and to smooth the amount available for spending, reducing the operational impact of any investment volatility. A total return for spending of £5.1m was applied in the year, meaning £1.8m of historical gains were available from investments for spending.
The College transferred two residential properties into property investments in the year as these properties are now being used as investment rather than operational assets. At the time of transfer, the net book value of the properties was £9k and the value of the properties was £926k. These are unrestricted assets, and the valuation gain is included within unrestricted funds.
The total investment gain in the year is £10.7m, reflecting a 7.5% capital return in the year. The College has withdrawn a net £0.7m in investments during the year, relating to maturing investments. The College’s Investment Committee is undertaking a detailed portfolio review and will assess whether any changes need to be made to the portfolio structure during the coming year.
The net income before gains of £0.9m (2023: £3.6m) reflects the positive £1.8m movement in pension deficit, following the 2023 valuation of the Universities Superannuation Scheme (see note 22) and a depreciation charge of £2m (note 10) which reflects the depreciation charge on the new accommodation at the Master’s Field. Without these non-cash adjustments, the net income before gains would have been £1.1m.
Investment policy, objectives and performance
The Investment Committee reviews the College’s investment strategy each year, with the investment objective to preserve, and preferably grow, the real value of its assets over the long-term, after providing for annual distributions whilst taking acceptable levels of risk. The investment policy is to hold a globally diversified portfolio of investments across a range of asset classes. It is constructed to seek to maximise the probability of attaining a level of total return that at least preserves the long-term real value of the portfolio.
The College’s investments are managed on a total return basis, maintaining diversification across a range of asset classes including public and private equity, property and bonds. It aims to produce an appropriate balance between risk and return. Under the total return accounting basis, it is the Governing Body’s policy to extract as income 3.25% of the value of the endowment. However, to smooth and moderate the amounts withdrawn this 3.25% is calculated on the weighted and indexed average of the endowment over a four-year period using the value as at the 31 March each year.
In December 2015 the College issued a private placement bond to fund the development of the additional student accommodation around the Master’s Field. The placement, of £35m, at a fixed rate of 3.37% for a period of 45 years, was invested in low-risk investments with the aim of drawing down capital as required to fund the project until its practical completion in May 2021. The income from the development, after allowing for interest payments of £1.2m per year, will be set-aside to repay the capital balance due in 2060.
16
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Reserves policy
The College’s reserves policy is to maintain sufficient free reserves to enable it to meet its short-term financial obligations in the event of an unexpected revenue shortfall, to allow the College to be managed efficiently and to provide a buffer that would ensure uninterrupted services. This also allows for the payments of £1.2m per year in interest for its fixed rate bond. The College reviews its reserves policy on an annual basis. This encompasses a review of the operational cash outflows of the College to ensure that adequate liquid reserves are held to cover an unexpected and rapid decline in the College’s incomegenerating activities or an uninsured catastrophic failure.
The College’s short-term financial needs are defined with reference to a multiple of the College’s underlying monthly operational expenditure, both restricted and unrestricted, with a reserves target in 2023/24 of £2.0-3.0m. Such reserves are designed to allow for the financial impact should the College face an unforeseen downturn or significant event which has an adverse financial impact. At 31 July 2024 the restricted and unrestricted reserves, excluded designated funds, amounted to £16.4m (2023: £10.7m), with many restricted reserves committed to expenditure within the next year, such as Fellowship, Student Support and Outreach activities.
Total funds of the College and its subsidiary at the year-end amounted to £179m (2023: £168m). This includes endowment capital of £154m and unspent restricted income funds totalling £4.6m. Free reserves at the year-end amounted to £11m (2023: £5.7m), representing retained unrestricted income reserves of £21m (2023: £17m) excluding the book value of tangible fixed assets funds (less allocated bond funding associated with the assets under construction) of £9m (2023: £11m) and, in 2023, the pension funding agreement reserve (2023: £2m).
Grant making
The College operates a generous programme of financial assistance grants, awarded on the basis of financial need by the Student Finance Committee and awarded grants to the value of £144,000 in the financial year (2023: £153,000). It also offers scholarships, prizes and academic project grants to students with £1.7m awarded in 2023 (2023: £1.4m).
The College also provides grants to schools within its link areas of Hertfordshire, Norfolk and Suffolk to support specific outreach activities and provided grants of £30k (2023: £30k) as part of a three-year programme for three schools.
Risk management
The College has on-going processes which operated throughout the financial year for identifying, evaluating and managing the principal risks and uncertainties faced by the College and its subsidiary in undertaking their activities. The College considers its principal risks to be the health and safety risks in operating a large site, the protection of sensitive data and the recruitment and retention of high calibre staff. When it is not able to address risk issues using internal resources, the College takes advice from experts external to the College with specialist knowledge. Policies and procedures within the College are reviewed by the relevant College Committee. Financial risks are assessed by the Executive Committee and investment risks are monitored by the Investment Committee. Training courses and other forms of career development are available to members of staff to enhance their skills in risk-related areas.
The Governing Body, who have ultimate responsibility for managing any risks faced by the College, have reviewed the processes in place for managing risk and the principal identified risks to which the College and its subsidiaries are exposed and have concluded that adequate systems are in place to manage these risks.
17
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Statement of accounting and reporting responsibilities
The Governing Body is responsible for preparing the Report of the Governing Body and the financial statements in accordance with applicable law and regulations.
Charity law requires the Governing Body to prepare financial statements for each financial year. Under that law the Governing Body have prepared the financial statements in accordance United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accounting Practice (United Kingdom Accounting Standards and applicable law), including Financial Reporting Standard 102: The Financial Reporting Standard Applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland (FRS 102).
Under charity law the Governing Body must not approve the financial statements unless they are satisfied that they give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the College and of its net income or expenditure for that period. In preparing these financial statements, the Governing Body is required to:
-
select the most suitable accounting policies and then apply them consistently;
-
make judgments and accounting estimates that are reasonable and prudent;
-
state whether applicable accounting standards, including FRS 102, have been followed, subject to any material departures disclosed and explained in the financial statements;
-
state whether a Statement of Recommended Practice (SORP) applies and has been followed, subject to any material departures which are explained in the financial statements.
-
prepare the financial statements on the going concern basis unless it is inappropriate to presume that the College will continue to operate.
The Governing Body is responsible for keeping proper accounting records that are sufficient to show and explain the College’s transactions and disclose with reasonable accuracy at any time the financial position of the College and enable them to ensure that the financial statements comply with the Charities Act 2011. They are also responsible for safeguarding the assets of the College and ensuring their proper application under charity law and hence for taking reasonable steps for the prevention and detection of fraud and other irregularities.
Approved by the Governing Body on 13[th] November 2024 and signed on its behalf by:
Dame Helen Ghosh, Master.
18
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Independent Auditor’s Report to the Trustees of Balliol College
Opinion
We have audited the financial statements of Balliol College (‘the Charity’) and its subsidiary (‘the group’) for the year ended 31 July 2024 which comprise the Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities, Consolidated and College Balance Sheet, Consolidated Cash Flow Statement and notes to the financial statements, including significant accounting policies. The financial reporting framework that has been applied in their preparation is applicable law and United Kingdom Accounting Standards, including Financial Reporting Standard 102 The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland (United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accounting Practice).
In our opinion the financial statements:
-
give a true and fair view of the state of the group’s and the parent charity’s affairs as at 31 July 2024 and of the group’s income and receipts of endowments and expenditure, for the year then ended;
-
have been properly prepared in accordance with United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accounting Practice; and
-
have been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the Charities Act 2011.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK) (ISAs (UK)) and applicable law. Our responsibilities under those standards are further described in the Auditor’s responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements section of our report. We are independent of the group in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit of the financial statements in the UK, including the FRC’s Ethical Standard, and we have fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with these requirements. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Conclusions relating to going concern
In auditing the financial statements, we have concluded that the trustee's use of the going concern basis of accounting in the preparation of the financial statements is appropriate.
Based on the work we have performed, we have not identified any material uncertainties relating to events or conditions that, individually or collectively, may cast significant doubt on the charity or the group’s ability to continue as a going concern for a period of at least twelve months from when the financial statements are authorised for issue.
Our responsibilities and the responsibilities of the trustees with respect to going concern are described in the relevant sections of this report.
Other information
The trustees are responsible for the other information contained within the annual report. The other information comprises the information included in the annual report, other than the financial statements and our auditor’s report thereon. Our opinion on the financial statements does not cover the other information and, except to the extent otherwise explicitly stated in our report, we do not express any form of assurance conclusion thereon.
Our responsibility is to read the other information and, in doing so, consider whether the other information is materially inconsistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the audit or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If we identify such material inconsistencies or apparent material misstatements, we are required to determine whether this gives rise to a material misstatement in
19
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
the financial statements themselves. If, based on the work we have performed, we conclude that there is a material misstatement of this other information, we are required to report that fact.
We have nothing to report in this regard.
Matters on which we are required to report by exception
We have nothing to report in respect of the following matters in relation to which the Charities (Accounts and Reports) Regulations 2008 requires us to report to you if, in our opinion:
-
the information given in the financial statements is inconsistent in any material respect with the trustees’ report; or
-
sufficient and proper accounting records have not been kept by the parent charity; or
-
the financial statements are not in agreement with the accounting records and returns; or
-
we have not received all the information and explanations we require for our audit
Responsibilities of trustees
As explained more fully in the trustees’ responsibilities statement, the trustees are responsible for the preparation of the financial statements and for being satisfied that they give a true and fair view, and for such internal control as the trustees determine is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, the trustees are responsible for assessing the group and the parent Charity’s ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accounting unless the trustees either intend to liquidate the charity or to cease operations, or have no realistic alternative but to do so.
Auditor’s responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements
We have been appointed as auditor under section 151 of the Charities Act 2011, and report in accordance with the Acts and relevant regulations made or having effect thereunder.
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditor’s report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs (UK) will always detect a material misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial statements.
Details of the extent to which the audit was considered capable of detecting irregularities, including fraud and non-compliance with laws and regulations are set out below.
A further description of our responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements is located on the Financial Reporting Council’s website at: www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibilities. This description forms part of our auditor’s report.
Extent to which the audit was considered capable of detecting irregularities, including fraud
Irregularities, including fraud, are instances of non-compliance with laws and regulations. We identified and assessed the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements from irregularities, whether due to fraud or error, and discussed these between our audit team. We then designed and performed audit procedures responsive to those risks, including obtaining audit evidence sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
20
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
We obtained an understanding of the legal and regulatory frameworks within which the parent charity and group operates, focusing on those laws and regulations that have a direct effect on the determination of material amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. The laws and regulations we considered in this context were taxation legislation, together with the Charities SORP (FRS 102). We assessed the required compliance with these laws and regulations as part of our audit procedures on the related financial statement items.
In addition, we considered provisions of other laws and regulations that do not have a direct effect on the financial statements but compliance with which might be fundamental to the parent charity’s and the group’s ability to operate or to avoid a material penalty. We also considered the opportunities and incentives that may exist within the parent charity and the group for fraud. The other laws and regulations we considered in this context for the group were General Data Protection Regulations and Health and Safety.
Auditing standards limit the required audit procedures to identify non-compliance with these laws and regulations to enquiry of the Trustees and other management and inspection of regulatory and legal correspondence, if any.
We identified the greatest risk of material impact on the financial statements from irregularities, including fraud, to be within the recognition of certain income streams, and the override of controls by management. Our audit procedures to respond to risk of income recognition within the income streams deemed to be a greatest risk included selecting a sample of income during the year, agreeing to the relevant documentation and ensuring it has been recognised correctly. Our audit procedures to respond to the risk of management override included enquiries of management about their own identification and assessment of the risks of irregularities, sample testing on the posting of journals, reviewing accounting estimates for biases, reviewing minutes of meetings of those charged with governance.
Owing to the inherent limitations of an audit, there is an unavoidable risk that we may not have detected some material misstatements in the financial statements, even though we have properly planned and performed our audit in accordance with auditing standards. For example, the further removed noncompliance with laws and regulations (irregularities) is from the events and transactions reflected in the financial statements, the less likely the inherently limited procedures required by auditing standards would identify it. In addition, as with any audit, there remained a higher risk of non-detection of irregularities, as these may involve collusion, forgery, intentional omissions, misrepresentations, or the override of internal controls. We are not responsible for preventing non-compliance and cannot be expected to detect noncompliance with all laws and regulations.
Use of our report
This report is made solely to the charity’s trustees, as a body, in accordance with Part 4 of the Charities (Accounts and Reports) Regulations 2008. Our audit work has been undertaken so that we might state to the charity’s trustees those matters we are required to state to them in an auditor’s report and for no other purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we do not accept or assume responsibility to anyone other than the charity and the charity’s trustees as a body, for our audit work, for this report, or for the opinions we have formed.
21
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
[This report has not yet been signed]
CROWE U.K. LLP
Statutory Auditor
5[th] Floor R+ Building 2 Blagrave Street Reading RG1 1AZ
Date:
Crowe U.K. LLP is eligible for appointment as auditor of the charity by virtue of its eligibility for appointment as auditor of a company under section 1212 of the Companies Act 2006
22
Balliol College Year ended 31 July 2024
Statement of Principal Accounting Policies
Scope of the financial statements
The financial statements present the Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities (SOFA), the Consolidated and College Balance Sheets and the Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows for the College and its wholly owned subsidiary Balliol College Developments Limited . No separate SOFA or statement of cash flows have been presented for the College alone as currently permitted by FRS102: The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland.
A summary of the results and financial position of the charity and its subsidiary for the reporting year are set out in note 13.
1. Basis of accounting
The College’s individual and consolidated financial statements have been prepared in accordance with United Kingdom Accounting Standards, in particular ‘FRS 102: The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland’ (FRS 102).
The College is a public benefit entity for the purposes of FRS 102 and a registered charity. The College has therefore also prepared its individual and consolidated financial statements in accordance with ‘Accounting and Reporting by Charities: Statement of Recommended Practice applicable to charities preparing their accounts in accordance with the Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland’ (The Charities SORP (FRS 102), second edition – October 2019.
The financial statements have been prepared on the historical cost basis, except for the measurement of investments and certain financial assets and liabilities at fair value with movements in value reported within the Statement of Financial Activities (‘SOFA’).
The principal accounting policies adopted are set out below and have been applied consistently throughout the year.
2. Going concern basis
The financial statements have been prepared on the going concern basis. The College and its subsidiary have sufficient cash and investment resources to continue in operational existence for the foreseeable future and have no further requirement for external funding.
3. Accounting judgments and estimation uncertainty
In preparing financial statements it is necessary to make certain judgments, estimates and assumptions that affect the amounts recognised in the financial statements. The following judgments and estimates are considered by the Governing Body to have most significant effect on amounts recognised in the financial statements.
Recognition of legacies: Before legacies are recognised in the financial statements, the Governing Body has to exercise judgment as to what constitutes sufficient evidence of entitlement to the bequest. Sufficient entitlement exists once notification of payment has been received from the executor(s) of the estate or estate accounts are available which indicate there are sufficient funds in the estate after meeting liabilities for the bequest to be paid.
Investments, including property investments and other investments : The investments held by the College are included at fair value. These valuations are based on information prepared by the relevant investment managers or professionally qualified surveyors.
With respect to the next financial year, the most significant areas of uncertainty that affect the carrying value of assets held by the College are the level of investment return and the performance of the investment and property markets.
23
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
Liability for the deficit recovery plans associated with multi-employer pension schemes : FRS 102 makes the distinction between a group plan and a multi-employer scheme. A group plan consists of a collection of entities under common control typically with a sponsoring employer. A multi-employer scheme is a scheme for entities not under common control such as the Universities Superannuation Scheme and OSPS. The accounting for a multi-employer scheme where the employer has entered into an agreement with the scheme that determines how the employer will fund a deficit results in the recognition of a liability for the contributions payable that arise from the agreement (to the extent that they relate to the deficit) and the resulting expense in profit or loss in accordance with section 28 of FRS 102. The Trustees are satisfied that USS and OSPS meet the definition of a multi-employer scheme and the College has therefore recognised the discounted fair value of the contractual contributions under the recovery plan in existence at the date of approving these financial statements.
The pension deficits recorded are dependent on estimates of future employment patterns and interest rates. The effects of changes to these assumptions are shown in note 22.
4. Basis of consolidation
The consolidated statement of financial activities, the consolidated balance sheet and the consolidated cash flow statement include the financial statements of the College and its subsidiary made up to 31 July 2024, using uniform accounting policies. Intra group transactions are eliminated fully on consolidation.
5. Investment in subsidiary undertaking
The investment in the College’s subsidiary undertaking is recorded at cost plus incidental expenses less any provision for impairment. Impairment reviews are performed by the trustees when there has been an indication of potential impairment.
6. Incoming resources from fee income, Office for Students’ support and other charges for services
Fees receivable, Office for Students’ support and charges for services and use of the premises, less any scholarships, bursaries or other allowances granted by the College, but including contributions received from restricted funds, are accounted for in the period in which the related service is provided.
7. Incoming resources from donations and legacies
Voluntary income is accounted for when the College has entitlement to the funds, the amount can be measured reliably and receipt is probable.
Voluntary income received for the general purpose of the College is credited to unrestricted funds.
Voluntary income which is subject to specific wishes of the donor is credited to the relevant restricted fund or, where the donation, grant or legacy is required to be held as capital, to the endowment funds. Where voluntary income is received otherwise than in cash, it is valued at the market value of the underlying assets received at the date of recognition.
8. Incoming resources from grants
Grant income is recognised when the terms of the grant have been met. The College has received grant income associated with a project regarding the information environment and Government grant income for the preparation of a heat decarbonisation plan. Income has been recognised when there is evidence of entitlement, receipt is probable and its amount can be measured reliably. This has generally been on receipt of the income.
9. Investment income
Interest on bank balances and fixed interest securities is accounted for in the period to which the interest relates.
Dividend income and similar distributions are accounted for in the period in which they become receivable.
24
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
10. Expenditure
Expenditure is accounted for on an accruals basis. A liability and related expenditure is recognised when there is a present legal or constructive obligation at the reporting date as a result of a past event, it is probably that a transfer of economic benefit will be required in settlement and the amount of the obligation can be measured or estimated reliably.
Indirect expenditure is apportioned to expenditure categories based on the estimated amount attributable to that activity in the year, either by reference to staff time or the use made of the underlying assets, as appropriate. Irrecoverable VAT is included with the item of expenditure to which it relates.
Grants awarded are expensed as soon as they become legal or operational commitments.
Governance costs comprise the costs of complying with constitutional and statutory requirements.
Intra-group sales and charges between the College and its subsidiary are excluded from trading income and expenditure.
11. Tangible fixed assets
Major expenditure on the acquisition, construction or enhancement of land and buildings and expenditure on equipment costing more than £10,000 is capitalised and carried in the balance sheet at historical cost. The cost of tangible fixed assets is their purchase cost together with any incidental expenses of acquisition.
Other expenditure on equipment incurred in the normal day-to-day running of the College and its subsidiary is charged to the Statement of Financial Activities as incurred.
12. Depreciation
Depreciation is provided to write off the cost of all relevant tangible fixed assets, less their estimated residual value, in equal annual instalments over their expected useful economic lives as follows:
| Freehold land and buildings, including major extensions | 50 years |
|---|---|
| Building improvements | 10 - 30 years |
| Fixtures, fittings and equipment | 5 - 10 years |
A full year’s depreciation is charged in year of purchase, unless the asset is under construction, in which case depreciation is charged from the month in which the asset is brought into economic use. Freehold land is not depreciated.
13. Heritage assets
The College has a number of assets that meet the definition of heritage assets under the Charities SORP (FRS102). Reliable information on cost or value is not available for all these assets and such information cannot be obtained at a cost commensurate with the benefit to the users of the financial statements or to the College. Therefore, no cost or value is reflected for heritage assets within the financial statements.
14. Investments
Listed investments are valued at their mid-market values as at the balance sheet date. Investments such as hedge funds and private equity funds which have no readily identifiable market value are included at the most recent valuations from their respective managers. Property investments are valued based on the advice of professionally qualified surveyors, on an arm’s length basis, that is between a willing buyer and a willing seller.
Gains and losses arising on the investments are credited or charged to the Statement of Financial Activities and are allocated to the appropriate Fund according to the “ownership” of the underlying assets.
25
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
15. Stocks
Stocks are valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value, cost being the purchase price on a first in, first out basis.
16. Foreign currencies
Transactions denominated in foreign currencies during the year are translated at prevailing rates of exchange at the dates of the transactions. Monetary assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies are translated into sterling at rates applying at the Balance Sheet date or, where there are related forward foreign exchange contracts, at the contract rates. The resulting exchange differences are taken to the Statement of Financial Activities.
17. Total Return investment accounting
The College statutes authorise the College to adopt a ‘total return’ basis for the investment of its endowment. The College can invest its endowments without regard to the capital/income distinctions of trust law and with discretion to apply any part of the accumulated total return on the investment as income for spending each year.
18. Fund accounting
The total funds of the College and its subsidiaries are allocated to unrestricted, restricted or endowment funds based on the origins of the funds and the terms set by the donors. Endowment funds are further sub-divided into permanent and expendable.
Unrestricted funds can be used in furtherance of the objects of the College at the discretion of the Governing Body. The Governing Body may decide that part of the unrestricted funds shall be used in future for a specific purpose and this will be accounted for by transfers to appropriate designated funds.
Restricted funds comprise gifts, legacies and grants where the donors have earmarked funds for specific purposes. They consist of either gifts where the donor has specified that both the capital and any income arising must be used for the purposes given or the income on gifts where the donor has required that the capital be maintained and the income used for specific purposes.
Permanent endowment funds arise where donors specify that the funds should be retained as capital for the permanent benefit of the College. Expendable endowment funds are similar to permanent endowment in that they have been given, or the College has determined based on the circumstances that they have been given, for the long-term benefit of the College. However, the Governing Body may at their discretion determine to spend all or part of the capital. Any income arising from the capital will be accounted for as unrestricted funds unless the donor has restricted the use of that income, in which case it will be accounted for as a restricted fund.
19. Pension costs
The College participates in the Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS) and the University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme (OSPS). These schemes are hybrid pension schemes, providing defined benefits as well as benefits based on defined contributions. The assets of each scheme are held in a separate trusteeadministered fund. Because of the mutual nature of the schemes, the assets are not attributed to individual employers and scheme-wide contribution rates are set. The College is therefore exposed to actuarial risks associated with other employers’ employees and is unable to identify its share of the underlying assets and liabilities of the schemes on a consistent and reasonable basis.
As required by Section 28 of FRS 102 “Employee benefits”, the College therefore accounts for the schemes as if they were wholly defined contribution schemes. As a result, the amount charged to the profit and loss account represents the contributions payable to each scheme. Since the College has entered into agreements (the Recovery Plans) that determine how each employer within the schemes will fund the overall deficit, the College recognises a liability for the contributions payable that arise from the agreements (to the extent that they relate to the deficit) with related expenses being recognised through the profit and loss account.
26
Balliol College
Year ended 31 July 2024
20. Financial instruments
Financial instruments are classified and accounted for according to the substance of the contractual arrangement, as either financial assets or financial liabilities. The College and Group only have financial assets and liabilities that are classified as basic financial instruments. Most basic financial instruments are initially recognised at transaction value and subsequently measured at their settlement value, which is not materially different to amortised cost.
The long-term bond, entered into in December 2015, is subsequently measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method.
27
Balliol College
Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities For the year ended 31 July 2024
| Note INCOME AND ENDOWMENTS FROM: Charitable activities: Teaching, research and residential 1 Other trading income 2 Donations and legacies 3 Investments Investment income 4 Total return allocated to income 14 Other income 5 Total income EXPENDITURE ON: 6 Charitable activities: Teaching, research and residential Raising funds: Fundraising Trading expenditure Total expenditure Net (expenditure) / income before gains Net (losses)/gains on investments Net (expenditure) / income Transfers between funds 18 Net movement in funds for the year Fund balances brought forward 18 Funds carried forward at 31 July |
Unrestricted Funds £'000 9,075 2,606 1,498 283 1,494 115 |
Restricted Funds £'000 - - 1,514 - 3,689 1,261 |
Endowment Funds £'000 31 - 422 3,054 (5,183) - |
2024 Total £'000 9,106 2,606 3,434 3,337 - 1,376 |
2023 Total £'000 8,199 2,606 7,566 3,010 - 926 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15,071 10,806 795 1,836 |
6,464 5,459 - - |
(1,676) 29 - - |
19,859 16,294 795 1,836 |
22,307 16,154 719 1,798 |
|
| 13,438 | 5,459 | 29 | 18,926 | 18,671 | |
| 1,633 | 1,005 | (1,705) | 933 | 3,636 | |
| 917 | - | 9,806 | 10,723 | (4,197) | |
| 2,550 | 1,005 | 8,101 | 11,656 | (561) | |
| 1,085 | (1,326) | 241 | - | - | |
| 3,635 16,965 |
(321) 4,921 |
8,342 145,741 |
11,656 167,627 |
(561) 168,188 |
|
| 20,600 | 4,600 | 154,083 | 179,283 | 167,627 |
The notes on pages 31 to 46 are an integral part of these financial statements.
28
Balliol College
Consolidated and College Balance Sheets As at 31 July 2024
| Note FIXED ASSETS Tangible assets 10 Property investments 11 Other investments 12 Total fixed assets CURRENT ASSETS Stocks Debtors 15 Cash at bank and in hand Total current assets LIABILITIES Creditors: Amounts falling due within one year 16 NET CURRENT ASSETS TOTAL ASSETS LESS CURRENT LIABILITIES CREDITORS: Amounts falling due after more than one year 17 Defined benefit pension scheme liability 22 TOTAL NET ASSETS FUNDS OF THE COLLEGE Endowment funds 18 Restricted funds 18 Unrestricted funds Designated funds 18 General funds 18 Pension reserve 22 TOTAL FUNDS NET ASSETS BEFORE PENSION LIABILITY |
2024 Group £'000 57,707 1,980 152,198 |
2023 Group £'000 57,639 - 144,213 |
2024 College £'000 57,707 1,980 152,198 |
2023 College £'000 57,639 - 144,213 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 211,885 | 201,852 | 211,885 | 201,852 | |
| 64 3,094 2,677 |
62 2,041 3,634 |
63 2,423 2,538 |
62 1,624 3,489 |
|
| 5,835 3,694 |
5,737 3,393 |
5,024 3,046 |
5,175 2,983 |
|
| 2,141 | 2,344 | 1,978 | 2,192 | |
| 214,026 34,743 |
204,196 34,740 |
213,863 34,743 |
204,044 34,740 |
|
| 179,283 - |
169,456 1,829 |
179,120 - |
169,304 1,829 |
|
| 179,283 | 167,627 | 179,120 | 167,475 | |
| 154,083 4,600 9,253 11,347 - |
145,741 4,921 11,225 7,569 (1,829) |
154,083 4,600 9,253 11,184 - |
145,741 4,921 11,225 7,417 (1,829) |
|
| 179,283 | 167,627 | 179,120 | 167,475 |
The financial statements were approved and authorised for issue by the Governing Body of Balliol College on 13th November 2024.
Dame Helen Ghosh, Master
Mrs Amanda Tilley, Finance Bursar
The notes on pages 31 to 46 are an integral part of these financial statements.
29
Balliol College
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows
For the year ended 31 July 2024
| Note Cashflows from operating activities: Net cash used in operating activities 24 Cash flows from investing activities Dividends and interest from investments Proceeds from the sale of property, plant and equipment Purchase of property, plant and equipment Proceeds from sale of investments Purchase of investments Net cash used in investing activities Cash flows from financing activities Repayments of borrowing Receipt of endowment Net cash provided by financing activities Change in cash and cash equivalents in the reporting year Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the reporting year 26 Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the reporting year |
2024 £'000 (3,421) 3,354 - (2,078) 40,677 (39,911) 2,042 - 422 422 (957) 3,634 2,677 |
2023 £'000 (3,752) |
|---|---|---|
| 3,323 - (241) 902 (9,249) |
||
| (5,265) | ||
| 5,026 | ||
| 5,026 | ||
| (3,991) | ||
| 7,625 | ||
| 3,634 |
The notes on pages 31 to 46 are an integral part of these financial statements.
30
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
1 INCOME FROM CHARITABLE ACTIVITIES
| Teaching, research and residential Unrestricted funds Tuition fees - UK and EU students Tuition fees - Overseas students Other fees Other Office for Students support Other academic income College residential income Endowed funds College residential income Total teaching, research and residential Total income from charitable activities |
2024 £'000 1,786 2,092 19 257 179 4,742 9,075 31 31 9,106 9,106 |
2023 £'000 1,766 1,779 - 273 139 4,190 |
|---|---|---|
| 8,147 | ||
| 52 | ||
| 52 | ||
| 8,199 | ||
| 8,199 |
The above analysis includes £4,135k received from the University of Oxford from publicly accountable funds under the CFF Scheme (2023: £3,822k).
To support the strategic priority to fund more graduate scholars and to enable outstanding students to take up their places regardless of their financial position, the College has waived £114k (2023: £36k). These waivers related to graduate students with overseas fee status funded through the Clarendon or UKRI scholarship funding schemes. These are not included in the fee income reported above.
2 OTHER TRADING INCOME
| Conference, catering and trading income DONATIONS AND LEGACIES Donations and legacies Unrestricted funds Restricted funds Endowment funds |
2024 £'000 2,606 2,606 2024 £'000 1,498 1,514 422 3,434 |
2023 £'000 2,606 |
|---|---|---|
| 2,606 | ||
| 2023 £'000 641 1,899 5,026 |
||
| 7,566 |
3 DONATIONS AND LEGACIES
4 INVESTMENT INCOME
| Unrestricted funds Bank interest Other investment income Endowment funds Investment income Total investment income OTHER INCOME Unrestricted funds Other income Restricted funds Nursery income Income received from Government grants Income received from other grants Other income Total other income |
2024 £'000 263 20 283 3,054 3,054 3,337 2024 £'000 115 115 252 67 920 22 1,261 1,376 |
2023 £'000 225 11 |
|---|---|---|
| 236 | ||
| 2,774 | ||
| 2,774 | ||
| 3,010 | ||
| 2023 £'000 113 |
||
| 113 | ||
| 242 - 545 26 |
||
| 813 | ||
| 926 |
5 OTHER INCOME
31
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
| 6 ANALYSIS OF EXPENDITURE Charitable expenditure Direct staff costs allocated to: Teaching, research and residential Other direct costs allocated to: Teaching, research and residential Support and governance costs allocated to: Teaching, research and residential Total charitable expenditure Expenditure on raising funds Direct staff costs allocated to: Fundraising Trading expenditure Other direct costs allocated to: Fundraising Trading expenditure Support and governance costs allocated to: Fundraising Trading expenditure Total expenditure on raising funds Total expenditure |
2024 £'000 7,014 6,685 2,595 16,294 549 1,372 189 369 57 95 2,632 18,926 |
2023 £'000 6,697 5,915 3,542 |
|---|---|---|
| 16,154 | ||
| 506 1,290 160 435 53 73 |
||
| 2,517 | ||
| 18,671 |
The College is liable to be assessed for a contribution under the provisions Statute XV of the University of Oxford which allows for a Contribution Fund which is used to make grants and loans to colleges of the University of Oxford on the basis of need. The scheme has been approved by the Council of the University, Congregation and His Majesty in Council. The contribution under the scheme is payable during the financial year and is included within charitable expenditure (2024: £76k, 2023: £77k).
A foreign exchange gain of £5k (2023: loss of £21k) is reflected in other income (2023: financial administration costs).
7 ANALYSIS OF SUPPORT AND GOVERNANCE COSTS
| Financial administration Domestic administration Human resources IT Depreciation Other finance charges Governance costs Financial administration IT Depreciation Other finance charges Governance costs |
Generating Funds £'000 78 30 - 42 - - 3 153 Generating Funds £'000 96 30 - - - 126 |
Teaching and Research £'000 357 416 48 353 2,032 (646) 35 2,595 Teaching and Research £'000 1,207 123 1,981 197 34 3,542 |
2024 Total £'000 435 446 48 395 2,032 (646) 38 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2,748 | |||
| 2023 Total £'000 1,303 153 1,981 197 34 |
|||
| 3,668 |
Financial administration, IT and human resources costs are attributed according to the estimated staff time spent on each activity. Depreciation costs are attributed according to the use made of the underlying assets. Interest and other finance charges are attributed according to the purpose of the related financing. Governance costs are allocated according to the type of work undertaken.
32
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
7 ANALYSIS OF SUPPORT AND GOVERNANCE COSTS (continued)
| Governance costs comprise: Auditor's remuneration - audit services Auditor's remuneration - tax compliance services |
2024 £'000 35 3 38 |
2023 £'000 31 3 |
|---|---|---|
| 34 |
No amount has been included in governance costs for the direct employment costs or reimbursed expenses of the College Fellows on the basis that these payments relate to the Fellows involvement in the College's charitable activities. Details of the remuneration of the Fellows and their reimbursed expenses are included in note 20.
8 GRANTS AND AWARDS
| During the year the College funded research awards and bursaries to students from its restricted and unrestricted funds as follows: Unrestricted funds Grants to individuals: Scholarships, prizes and grants Bursaries and hardship awards Total unrestricted Restricted funds Grants to individuals: Scholarships, prizes and grants Bursaries and hardship awards Total restricted Total grants and awards |
2024 £'000 135 - 135 1,595 144 1,739 1,874 |
2023 £'000 215 29 |
|---|---|---|
| 244 | ||
| 1,234 124 |
||
| 1,358 | ||
| 1,602 |
The above costs are included within expenditure on charitable activities.
Included within the above is the cost to the College of the University of Oxford Bursary scheme. The College paid £70k in relation to this scheme in the year (2023: £81k).
9 STAFF COSTS
| The aggregate staff costs for the year were as follows. Salaries and wages Social security costs Pension costs: Defined benefit schemes Pension costs: Defined contribution schemes |
2024 £'000 8,208 690 (1,013) 209 8,094 |
2023 £'000 7,731 661 (46) 264 |
|---|---|---|
| 8,610 |
Redundancy and termination payments are accounted for in the period in which payments are made. During the current financial year, redundancy and termination payments were paid to two members of staff and amounted to £55k including pension contributions (2023: £nil). These costs are included in staff costs, above, and have been charged to unrestricted funds.
| The average number of employees of the College, excluding Trustees, on a full time equivalent basis was as follows: Tuition and research College residential Fundraising Support Total |
2024 Number 31 113 7 8 159 |
2023 Number 30 111 7 8 |
|---|---|---|
| 156 |
The average number of staff employed by the College, whether full-time or part-time, during the year was 159, excluding trustees. On average, a further 40 trustees were employed by the College during the year. The trustees do not receive remuneration for their roles as trustees but are employed in a different capacity.
| The average number of employed College Trustees during the year was as follows. Associate Professor Tutorial Fellow (University) Associate Professor Tutorial Fellow (College) Other teaching and research Other Total |
2024 Number 21 11 2 6 40 |
2023 Number 21 12 3 8 |
|---|---|---|
| 44 |
33
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
9 STAFF COSTS (continued)
The following information relates to the employees of the College, excluding the College Trustees. Details of the remuneration of the College Trustees are disclosed in a separate note in these financial statements.
The number of employees (excluding the College Trustees) during the year whose gross pay and benefits (excluding employers National Insurance and pension contributions) fell within the following bands was:
| £60,001-£70,000 £70,001-£80,000 The number of the above employees with retirement benefits accruing was as follows: In defined benefit schemes |
2 1 3 |
1 1 |
|---|---|---|
| 2 |
Details of the pension schemes are included in a separate note in these financial statements.
| 10 TANGIBLE ASSETS Group and College Cost At start of year Additions Transfer to investment properties At end of year Depreciation and impairment At start of year Charge for the year On disposals At end of year Net book value At end of year At start of year |
Freehold land and buildings £'000 63,586 1,778 (5) 65,359 8,447 1,342 (5) 9,784 55,575 55,139 |
Fixtures, fittings and equipment £'000 8,100 331 (21) 8,410 5,600 690 (12) 6,278 2,132 2,500 |
Total £'000 71,686 2,109 (26) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 73,769 | |||
| 14,047 2,032 (17) |
|||
| 16,062 | |||
| 57,707 | |||
| 57,639 |
No assets are held under finance leases.
The College has substantial long-held historic assets all of which are used in the course of the College’s teaching and research activities. These comprise listed buildings on the College site, together with their contents comprising works of art, ancient books and manuscripts and other treasured artefacts. Because of their age and, in many cases, unique nature, reliable historical cost information is not available for these assets and could not be obtained except at disproportionate expense. However, in the opinion of the Trustees the depreciated historical cost of these assets is now immaterial.
Houses and flats belonging to the College are intrinsically linked to the College operational activities so it is not considered appropriate to give a separate valuation of these properties. Where houses and flats are investment properties these are included at valuation within 'property investments' (note 11).
11 PROPERTY INVESTMENTS
| Group and College Valuation at start of year Transferred from fixed assets Transferred from other investments to disclose as property investments Additions Revaluation gains/(losses) in the year Valuation at end of year |
2024 £'000 - 8 150 905 917 1,980 |
2023 £'000 - - - - |
|---|---|---|
| - |
Property valuations as at 31 July have been made by an independent firm of Chartered Surveyors. The basis of valuation is market valuation, that is the estimated amount for which the assets would exchange between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's length transaction.
Property investments which are held indirectly through investment managers are included within 'other investments' in note 12.
34
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
12 OTHER INVESTMENTS
All investments are held at fair value.
| Group investments Valuation at start of year New money invested Amounts withdrawn Transferred to disclose as property investments Investment management fees Increase/(decrease) in value of investments Group investments at end of year Investment in subsidiaries College investments at end of year Group investments comprise: Equity investments Global multi-asset funds Property funds Fixed interest stocks Alternative and other investments Fixed term deposits and cash Total group investments |
Held outside Held in 2024 the UK the UK Total £'000 £'000 £'000 26,543 6,135 32,678 41,847 1,250 43,097 1,767 10,030 11,797 8,118 5,108 13,226 37,770 7,817 45,587 248 5,565 5,813 116,293 35,905 152,198 |
Held outside the UK £'000 21,091 51,080 3,056 1,827 25,077 5,331 107,462 |
2024 £'000 144,213 39,006 (40,677) (150) - 9,806 152,198 - 152,198 Held in the UK £'000 3,718 1,519 10,581 13,172 6,367 1,394 36,751 |
2023 £'000 140,063 9,249 (902) - - (4,197) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 144,213 - |
||||
| 144,213 | ||||
| 2023 Total £'000 24,809 52,599 13,637 14,999 31,444 6,725 |
||||
| 144,213 |
13 PARENT AND SUBSIDIARY UNDERTAKINGS
The College holds 100% of the issued share capital in Balliol College Developments Limited (Company number 04495361), a company providing building contractor, conference and other event services on the College premises.
The results and their assets and liabilities of the parent and subsidiary were as follows.
| Income Expenditure Net income before (losses)/gains on investments Net gains on investments Result for the year Total assets Total liabilities Net funds at the end of year |
£'000 18,169 (17,398) 771 10,723 11,494 216,909 (37,789) 179,120 20 Balliol College |
£'000 1,690 (1,528) 162 - 162 1,094 (932) 162 24 Balliol College Developments Limited |
£'000 22,250 (18,664) 3,586 (4,197) (611) 207,027 (39,552) 167,475 20 Balliol College |
£'000 1,598 (1,448) Balliol College Developments Limited 23 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 150 - |
||||
| 150 | ||||
| 775 (625) |
||||
| 150 |
During the year Balliol College Developments Limited charged Balliol College £18k (2023: £31k) for the cost for the development for the Master's Field. Balliol College charged Balliol College Developments Limited £1,654k (2023: £1,409k) for the use of College facilities and the use of College staff for Balliol College Developments Limited's conference and catering activities. At the year end the amount owed to Balliol College by Balliol College Developments Limited was £134k (2023: Owing to Balliol College Developments Limited £215k, see note 16).
35
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
14 STATEMENT OF INVESTMENT TOTAL RETURN
The Trustees have adopted a duly authorised policy of total return accounting for the College investment returns. The investment return to be applied as income is calculated as 3.25% of the weighted average of the value of the relevant investments as at 31 March in each of the last four years. The preserved (frozen) value of the invested endowment capital represents its open market value in 2012 together with all subsequent endowments valued at the date of gift.
The statement of investment total return is as follows:
| At the beginning of the year: Gift component of the permanent endowment Unapplied total return Expendable endowment Total Endowments Movements in the reporting year: Gift of endowment funds Investment return: total investment income Investment return: realised and unrealised gains and losses Other transfers Total Unapplied total return allocated to income in the reporting period Expendable endowments transferred to income Net movements in reporting year At end of the reporting year: Gift component of the permanent endowment Unapplied total return Expendable endowment Total Endowments |
Trust for Investment £'000 1,462 - - 1,462 - - - - - - - - - 1,462 - - 1,462 Pe |
Unapplied Total Return £'000 - 965 965 - 45 144 - 189 77 - 77 266 - 1,231 - 1,231 rmanent Endowm |
Total £'000 1,462 965 2,427 - 45 144 - 189 77 - 77 266 1,462 1,231 - 2,693 ent 2024 |
Expendable Endowment £'000 - - 143,314 143,314 422 3,040 9,662 212 13,336 (77) (5,183) (5,260) 8,076 - - 151,390 151,390 |
Total Endowments £'000 1,462 965 143,314 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 145,741 422 3,085 9,806 212 |
|||||
| 13,525 - (5,183) |
|||||
| (5,183) | |||||
| 8,342 1,462 1,231 151,390 |
|||||
| 154,083 |
- 14 STATEMENT OF INVESTMENT TOTAL RETURN (continued)
| STATEMENT OF INVESTMENT TOTAL RETURN (continued) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| At the beginning of the year: Gift component of the permanent endowment Unapplied total return Expendable endowment Total Endowments Movements in the reporting year: Gift of endowment funds Investment return: total investment income Investment return: realised and unrealised gains and losses Other transfers Total Unapplied total return allocated to income in the reporting period Expendable endowments transferred to income Net movements in reporting year At end of the reporting year: Gift component of the permanent endowment Unapplied total return Expendable endowment Total Endowments |
Trust for Investment £'000 1,462 - - 1,462 - - - - - - - - - 1,462 - - 1,462 Pe |
Unapplied Total Return £'000 - 909 - 909 - 42 (59) - (17) 73 - 73 56 - 965 - 965 rmanent Endowm |
Total £'000 1,462 909 - 2,371 - 42 (59) - (17) 73 - 73 56 1,462 965 - 2,427 ent 2023 |
Expendable Endowment £'000 - - 144,817 144,817 5,026 2,784 (4,138) (89) 3,583 (73) (5,013) (5,086) (1,503) - - 143,314 143,314 |
Total Endowments £'000 1,462 909 144,817 |
| 147,188 5,026 2,826 (4,197) (89) |
|||||
| 3,566 - (5,013) |
|||||
| (5,013) | |||||
| (1,447) 1,462 965 143,314 |
|||||
| 145,741 |
36
Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
Balliol College
| 15 DEBTORS Amounts falling due within one year: Trade debtors Amounts owed by College members Amounts owed by Group undertakings Prepayments and accrued income Other debtors |
2024 Group £'000 1,039 156 - 1,827 72 3,094 |
2023 Group £'000 659 138 - 1,181 63 2,041 |
2024 College £'000 234 156 134 1,827 72 2,423 |
2023 College £'000 243 138 - 1,180 63 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,624 |
| 16 CREDITORS: Amounts falling due within one year Trade creditors Amounts owed to College members Amounts owed to Group undertakings Taxation and social security Accruals and deferred income Other creditors 17 CREDITORS: falling due after more than one year Bond notes |
2024 Group £'000 480 203 - 328 1,215 1,468 3,694 2024 Group £'000 34,743 34,743 |
2023 Group £'000 418 167 - 286 1,159 1,363 3,393 2023 Group £'000 34,740 34,740 |
2024 College £'000 477 203 - 314 750 1,302 3,046 2024 College £'000 34,743 34,743 |
2023 College £'000 415 167 215 278 545 1,363 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2,983 | ||||
| 2023 College £'000 24,740 |
||||
| 24,740 |
In December 2015 the College entered into an unsecured note purchase agreement for £35m at a fixed rate of 3.37% with interest being payable half-yearly. The notes are due for repayment after 45 years, in December 2060.
37
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
18 ANALYSIS OF MOVEMENTS ON FUNDS
| Endowment Funds - Permanent War Memorial Fund 1919 Endowment Funds - Expendable General Fund 700th Anniversary Fund Alfred Douglas Stone Fund Andrew Graham Fellow in Economics Asoke Kumar Sarkar Fellowship in Classical Indology Classics Fellowship Fund Dan Norman Fund Dervorguilla Appeal Fund 1982 Dyson Fellowship in Greek Culture 1960 Early Career Fellows Endowment Fund Endowment Fund 1904 Fairfax Fellowships at Balliol College Foley-Bejar Scholarship Fund History Fellowships Fund James and Jane Ramage Scholarship Fund 2020 James Beeland Rogers Jr Endowment Fund John Henry Jones Scholarship Fund Jowett Centenary Fund Jowett Fellowship Fund Julian Huxley Memorial Fund JT Hamilton Legacy Fund Leveson Gower Bequest 1979 Lilian Margaret Gregson Fund Management Studies Fellowship Fund Maurice Lubbock Memorial Fund Michael and Clara Freeman Charitable Trust Mr Snell's Trust Oxford Internet Institute Fund Oxford-Rhodes-Balliol Scholarship Roy Skinner Fund Sigmar and Sabine Samwer Fund 2006 Victor Hugo Fund 2008 War Memorial Appeal Fund 1947 William Westerman Fund Yehan Numata Fund for Buddhist Studies Other Fellowship funds Other student support funds Other purpose funds Total Endowment Funds - Group and College Restricted Funds Unspent income from Trust funds and restricted revenue gifts Total Restricted Funds - Group and College Unrestricted Funds General Fixed asset designated fund Other designated fund Pension reserve Total Unrestricted Funds - College General Total Unrestricted Funds - Group Total Funds |
At 1 August 2023 £'000 2,145 42,944 13,276 874 1,875 1,476 3,703 1,444 6,432 845 3,174 3,288 4,279 2,436 4,169 1,030 1,316 1,996 2,734 1,082 735 1,092 851 1,013 1,226 1,557 816 987 4,680 1,332 1,357 785 806 1,132 1,193 3,578 4,636 10,418 7,029 145,741 4,921 4,921 7,419 11,225 - (1,829) 16,815 150 16,965 167,627 |
Incoming resources £'000 45 914 279 18 39 31 87 50 137 18 104 70 90 52 91 201 28 43 58 23 15 23 18 22 26 33 17 21 99 28 29 16 17 24 25 75 139 222 280 3,507 6,464 6,464 13,381 - - - 13,381 1,690 15,071 25,042 |
Resources expended £'000 - (29) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - (29) (5,459) (5,459) (11,569) (2,018) (2) 1,829 (11,760) (1,678) (13,438) (18,926) For the year en |
Transfers £'000 (77) (1,496) (473) (30) (66) (51) (132) (52) (227) (30) (112) (114) (152) (86) (148) (42) (46) (70) (97) (38) (26) (38) (30) (36) (43) (54) (29) (35) (165) (47) (47) (28) (29) (40) (42) (126) 104 (371) (321) (4,942) (1,326) (1,326) 1,037 - 48 - 1,085 - 1,085 (5,183) ded 31 July 202 |
Gains/ (losses) £'000 144 2,829 895 59 128 101 253 100 438 59 218 223 289 167 286 82 89 137 188 73 50 74 58 69 84 106 56 69 316 92 94 53 55 78 82 243 333 703 433 9,806 - - 917 - - 917 - 917 10,723 4 |
At 31 July 2024 £'000 2,257 45,162 13,977 921 1,976 1,557 3,911 1,542 6,780 892 3,384 3,467 4,506 2,569 4,398 1,271 1,387 2,106 2,883 1,140 774 1,151 897 1,068 1,293 1,642 860 1,042 4,930 1,405 1,433 826 849 1,194 1,258 3,770 5,212 10,972 7,421 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 154,083 | ||||||
| 4,600 | ||||||
| 4,600 | ||||||
| 11,185 9,207 46 - |
||||||
| 20,438 | ||||||
| 162 | ||||||
| 20,600 | ||||||
| 179,283 |
The total return applied to income, as shown on the Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities under incoming resources, is included within the transfers column.
38
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
18 ANALYSIS OF MOVEMENTS ON FUNDS (CONTINUED)
| Endowment Funds - Permanent War Memorial Fund 1919 Endowment Funds - Expendable General Fund 700th Anniversary Fund Alfred Douglas Stone Fund Andrew Graham Fellow in Economics Asoke Kumar Sarkar Fellowship in Classical Indology Classics Fellowship Fund Dan Norman Fund Dervorguilla Appeal Fund 1982 Dyson Fellowship in Greek Culture 1960 Early Career Fellows Endowment Fund Endowment Fund 1904 Fairfax Fellowships at Balliol College Foley-Bejar Scholarship Fund History Fellowships Fund James and Jane Ramage Scholarship Fund 2020 James Beeland Rogers Jr Endowment Fund John Henry Jones Scholarship Fund Jowett Centenary Fund Jowett Fellowship Fund JT Hamilton Legacy Fund Leveson Gower Bequest 1979 Lilian Margaret Gregson Fund Management Studies Fellowship Fund Maurice Lubbock Memorial Fund Michael and Clara Freeman Charitable Trust Mr Snell's Trust Oxford Internet Institute Fund Oxford-Rhodes-Balliol Scholarship Roy Skinner Fund Victor Hugo Fund 2008 War Memorial Appeal Fund 1947 William Westerman Fund Yehan Numata Fund for Buddhist Studies Other Fellowship funds Other student support funds Other purpose funds Total Endowment Funds - Group and College Endowment funds held by subsidiaries Total Endowment Funds - Group Restricted Funds Unspent income from Trust funds and restricted revenue gifts Other operational funds Total Restricted Funds - Group and College Unrestricted Funds General Fixed asset designated fund Designated maintenance funds Pension reserve Total Unrestricted Funds - College General Total Unrestricted Funds - Group Total Funds |
At 1 August 2022 £'000 2,235 44,972 13,842 912 1,948 1,541 3,835 1,399 6,714 883 3,279 3,434 118 2,544 4,351 900 1,374 2,085 2,855 1,130 1,140 889 1,057 1,280 1,626 852 1,031 4,882 1,391 1,418 840 1,182 1,244 3,734 4,246 11,592 8,433 147,188 - 147,188 4,590 - 4,590 5,915 13,209 - (2,815) 16,309 101 16,410 168,188 |
Incoming resources £'000 42 752 255 17 45 28 103 136 125 16 97 63 4,433 47 83 195 25 38 53 21 21 16 20 24 30 16 19 91 26 26 16 22 23 68 109 305 446 7,852 - 7,852 6,245 - 6,245 11,625 - - - 11,625 1,598 13,223 27,320 |
Resources expended £'000 - (48) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - (41) (89) - (89) (5,350) - (5,350) (10,685) (1,984) - 986 (11,683) (1,549) For the year en |
Transfers £'000 (73) (1,530) (456) (30) (64) (50) (127) (49) (220) (29) (109) (113) (147) (84) (143) (35) (45) (69) (94) (37) (37) (29) (34) (42) (54) (28) (34) (159) (46) (47) (27) (39) (40) (122) (141) (385) (245) (5,013) - (5,013) (564) - (564) 564 - - - 564 - 564 (5,013) ded 31 July 2023 |
Gains/ (losses) £'000 (59) (1,202) (365) (25) (54) (43) (108) (42) (187) (25) (93) (96) (125) (71) (122) (30) (38) (58) (80) (32) (32) (25) (30) (36) (45) (24) (29) (134) (39) (40) (23) (33) (34) (102) (120) (326) (270) (4,197) - (4,197) - - - - - - - - - - (4,197) |
At 31 July 2023 £'000 2,145 42,944 13,276 874 1,875 1,476 3,703 1,444 6,432 845 3,174 3,288 4,279 2,436 4,169 1,030 1,316 1,996 2,734 1,082 1,092 851 1,013 1,226 1,557 816 987 4,680 1,332 1,357 806 1,132 1,193 3,578 4,094 11,186 8,323 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 145,741 | ||||||
| - | ||||||
| 145,741 | ||||||
| 4,921 - |
||||||
| 4,921 | ||||||
| 7,419 11,225 - (1,829) |
||||||
| 16,815 | ||||||
| 150 | ||||||
| (13,232) | 16,965 | |||||
| (18,671) | 167,627 |
The total return applied to income, as shown on the Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities under incoming resources, is included within the transfers column.
39
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
18 FUNDS OF THE COLLEGE DETAILS
The following is a summary of the origins and purposes of each of the Funds. Only Funds which have a capital value in excess of £750,000 are separately identified.
| Endowment Funds - Permanent: | |
|---|---|
| War Memorial Fund 1920 | Capital balance of past donations to the War Memorial Fund 1920 where the related income, but |
| not the original capital, can be used for the restricted purpose of the charity. | |
| Endowment Funds - Expendable: | |
| General Fund | Capital balance of a consolidation of past gifts, donations and bequests where related income, or |
| income and capital, can be used for the restricted purpose of the College. | |
| 700th Anniversary Fund | Capital balance of the 1963 appeal to celebrate the 700th anniversary of the College. |
| Alfred Douglas Stone Fund | Established in 2004 to support College expenditure on student financial aid. |
| Andrew Graham Fellow in Economics | Established in 2011 to support College expenditure on a fellowship in economics. |
| Asoke Kumar Sarkar Fellowship Fund | Established in 2014 to fund a research fellowship in Classical Indology. |
| Classics Fellowship Fund | As a result of an appeal to support College expenditure on Classics fellowships. |
| Dan Norman Fund | To support research into addiction across biomedical, clinical, health and life sciences. |
| Dervorguilla Fund | Capital balance of gifts and donations to the 1980's Lady Dervorguilla Appeal. |
| Dyson Fellowship in Greek Culture 1960 | Established to support the a Fellowship in Greek culture. |
| Early Career Fellowship Fund | Established to support the costs of Career Development Fellows/Early Career Fellows. |
| Endowment Fund 1904 | Capital balance of the endowment appeal of 1904. |
| Fairfax Fellowships at Balliol College | Provide one or more fellowships in Philosophy or other subjects in the Honours Schools of Literae |
| Humaniores or Philosophy, Politics and Economics. | |
| Foley-Bejar Scholarship Fund | Established in 2001 to support College expenditure on student financial aid. |
| History Fellowships Fund | As a result of an appeal to support College expenditure on History fellowships. |
| James and Jane Ramage Scholarship Fund | To provide scholarships for women students of the College in a range of doctoral degrees in |
| science, technology, engineering, mathematics and medicine. | |
| James Beeland Rogers Jr Scholarship Fund | Established in 1991 to support College expenditure on student financial aid. |
| John Henry Jones Scholarship | Established in 2016 to support graduate scholarships. |
| Jowett Centenary Fund | Capital balance of gifts and donations to the 1990's appeal to celebrate the Jowett centenary. |
| Jowett Fellowship Fund | Established in 1907 to support College expenditure on fellowships. |
| JT Hamilton Legacy Fund | Gift in 2004 to support College expenditure on student financial aid. |
| Julian Huxley Memorial Fund | To support a Fellowship within biological or human sciences. |
| Leveson Gower Bequest 1979 | Established to support the study of Classics. |
| Lilian Margaret Gregson Fund | From a gift to support students of the College. |
| Management Studies Fellowship Fund | From a gift in 1996 for the support of management studies in the College and University. |
| Maurice Lubbock Memorial Fund | To support Engineering and Management studies. |
| Mr Snell's Trust | Established in 1677 to foster the connection between Glasgow and College. |
| Oxford Internet Institute Fund | From a gift in 2001 to support the Oxford Internet Institute which is located in the College. |
| Oxford-Rhodes-Balliol Scholarship | Established in 2017 to support graduate Rhodes scholars coming to the College. |
| Roy Skinner Fund | From a gift in 2001 to support College expenditure on student financial aid. |
| Sigmar & Sabine Samwer Fund 2006 | To support a studentship or bursary to students at Balliol in financial need |
| Victor Hugo Fund | Established to support a Fellowship in Modern Languages. |
| War Memorial Appeal Fund 1947 | As a result of an appeal in 1947 in memory of Balliol men who died during the War to support |
| expenditure on scholarships and fellowships. | |
| William Westerman Fund | Established in 2010 to support the Pathfinder Programme for visits by students to North America |
| and Australasia. | |
| Yehan Numata Fund for Buddhist Studies | Established in 1990 for the support of Buddhist studies in the College and University. |
| Other Fellowship funds | A consolidation of various funds established for the support of fellowships. |
| Other student support funds | A consolidation of various funds established for the support of student financial aid. |
| Other purpose funds | A consolidation of various funds established for the support of College expenditure on the library, |
| sport and the general academic purposes at the College. |
Restricted Funds: Trust Funds accumulated balances Accumulated cash balances of all the other Trust Funds held and administered by College. Other operational funds Various cash balances held by College from restricted purpose gifts.
The General Unrestricted Funds represent accumulated income from the College's activities and other sources that are available for the general purposes of the College.
40
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
19 ANALYSIS OF NET ASSETS BETWEEN FUNDS
| Tangible fixed assets Property and other investments Net current assets Long term liabilities (borrowing for acquisition of fixed assets) Pension liability Tangible fixed assets Other investments Net current assets Long term liabilities (borrowing for acquisition of fixed assets) Pension liability FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS Financial assets at fair value through Statement of Financial Activities: Fixed asset investments Financial instruments that are debt instruments measured at settlement value: Trade debtors Amounts owed by College members Other debtors and accrued income Financial liabilities measured at settlement value: Trade creditors Amounts owed to College members Amounts owed to Group undertakings Other creditors Accruals Other creditors Financial liabilities measured at amortised cost: Bond notes |
Unrestricted Funds £'000 56,202 925 (1,784) (34,743) - 20,600 Unrestricted Funds £'000 55,959 - (2,425) (34,740) (1,829) 16,965 2024 Group £'000 154,178 1,039 156 72 480 203 - 328 1,215 1,468 34,743 |
Restricted Funds £'000 675 - 3,925 - - 4,600 Restricted Funds £'000 152 - 4,769 - - 4,921 2023 Group £'000 144,213 659 138 63 418 167 - 286 1,159 1,363 34,740 |
Endowment Funds £'000 830 153,253 - - 154,083 Endowment Funds £'000 1,528 144,213 - - - 145,741 2024 College £'000 154,178 234 156 72 477 203 0 314 750 1,302 34,743 |
2024 Total £'000 57,707 154,178 2,141 (34,743) - |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 179,283 | ||||
| 2023 Total £'000 57,639 144,213 2,344 (34,740) (1,829) |
||||
| 167,627 | ||||
| 2023 College £'000 144,213 243 138 63 415 167 215 278 545 1,363 24,740 |
- 20 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
The fair values of the assets held at fair value through the Statement of Financial Activities are determined using valuations provided by the relevant investment managers.
- 21 TRUSTEES' REMUNERATION
The trustees of the college comprise the Governing Body, being Fellows who are teaching and research employees of the College, or Professorial Fellows with a College association, and who sit on the Governing Body by virtue of their employment or association with the College.
No trustee receives any remuneration for acting as a trustee. However, those trustees who are also employees of the College receive salaries for their work as employees. These salaries are paid on external academic and academic-related scales and often are joint arrangements with the University of Oxford.
Trustees of the College fall into the following categories:
Head of House
Professorial Fellow Tutorial Fellow Research Fellow
Non-Research Fellow
There are also four trustees who work on management and fundraising: the Head of House, Senior Tutor, Finance Bursar and Development Director.
Some trustees, particularly tutorial fellows, are eligible for college housing schemes. Twelve trustees live in houses owned by the College. Fellows may be eligible for a housing allowance which is disclosed within the salary figures below. In addition, some trustees receive additional allowances for additional work carried out as parttime College Officers, e.g. Tutor for Admissions, Vice Masters. These amounts are included within the remuneration figures disclosed.
Some trustees, together with other employees, are eligible for private health insurance as part of their package of remuneration and all trustees may eat at Common Table, as can all other employees who are entitled to meals whilst working.
The College has a Remuneration Committee which makes recommendations to Governing Body on pay and benefits which are outside of external scales. The Remuneration Committee consists of both external and internal members. Its membership is disclosed in the Report of the Governing Body.
24 trustees (2023: 21 trustees) are not employees of the college and do not receive remuneration.
41
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
21 TRUSTEES' REMUNERATION (continued)
Other transactions with trustees
No trustee claimed expenses for any work performed in discharge of duties as a trustee.
During the year, the College reached a settlement with the Chaplain, a trustee. Under the terms of the settlement, the Chaplain received compensation for early termination of his appointment. Including his salary to the date of termination, he received remuneration and taxable benefits amounting to £99,214 during the 2023/24 financial year. This figure includes income tax and pension contributions.
Additional information regarding trustees is included in the Related Party Transactions note.
Key management remuneration
Key management are considered to be the Head of House, Senior Tutor, Finance Bursar, Domestic Bursar and Development Director. The total remuneration paid to key management (Group and College) was £626k (2023: £641k).
Remuneration paid to trustees
| Remuneration paid to trustees | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 2023 | |||
| Range | Trustees / Fellows |
benefits and pension contributions |
Trustees / Fellows |
benefits and pension contributions |
| £0 £0,001-£1,000 £11,000-£11,999 £13,000-£13,999 £14,000-£14,999 £15,000-£15,999 £17,000-£17,999 £25,000-£25,999 £26,000-£26,999 £28,000-£28,999 £29,000-£29,999 £30,000-£30,999 £34,000-£34,999 £41,000-£41,999 £43,000-£43,999 £47,000-£47,999 £49,000-£49,999 £50,000-£50,999 £51,000-£51,999 £56,000-£56,999 £58,000-£58,999 £60,000-£60,999 £62,000-£62,999 £66,000-£66,999 £67,000-£67,999 £68,000-£68,999 £69,000-£69,999 £70,000-£70,999 £72,000-£72,999 £84,000-£84,999 £88,000-£88,999 £95,000-£95,999 £96,000-£96,999 £99,000-£99,999 £100,000-£100,999 £102,000-£102,999 £108,000-£108,999 £109,000-£109,999 £113,000-£113,999 £115,000-£115,999 £116,000-£116,999 £117,000-£117,999 £141,000-£141,999 £143,000-£143,999 Total |
24 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 12 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 |
£ 43,517 95,953 15,912 26,004 356,763 34,819 41,425 57,123 100,392 133,045 67,809 84,597 51,482 113,669 198,840 116,770 62,273 70,919 117,243 0 350 30,176 143,063 102,513 26,872 11,899 25,512 |
21 1 2 4 1 1 2 3 9 1 1 1 2 2 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 |
£ 30,652 34,239 85,056 264,975 17,392 53,874 43,081 60,477 94,655 68,360 72,477 113,437 99,972 88,819 132,464 116,260 100,019 108,313 96,587 109,819 141,035 115,757 22,622 50,806 0 14,945 169 53,519 |
| 67 | 2,128,936 | 67 | 2,189,781 |
42
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
22 PENSION SCHEMES
The College participates in two principal pension schemes - the Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS) and the University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme (OSPS). These schemes are hybrid pension schemes, providing defined benefits as well as benefits based on defined contributions. The assets of each scheme are held in a separate trustee-administered fund. Because of the mutual nature of the schemes, the assets are not attributed to individual employers and scheme-wide contribution rates are set. The College is therefore exposed to actuarial risks associated with other employers’ employees and is unable to identify its share of the underlying assets and liabilities of the schemes on a consistent and reasonable basis.
As required by Section 28 of FRS 102 “Employee Benefits”, the College therefore accounts for the schemes as if they were wholly defined contribution schemes. As a result, the amount charged to the income and expenditure account represents the contributions payable to each scheme and any deficit recovery contributions payable under a scheme Recovery Plan.
Where a scheme valuation determines that the scheme is in deficit on a technical provisions basis (as was the case following the 2020 USS valuation), the trustee of the scheme must agree a Recovery Plan that determines how each employer within the scheme will fund an overall deficit. The College recognises a liability for the contributions payable that arise from such an agreement (to the extent that they relate to a deficit) with related expenses being recognised through the income statement. Further disclosures relating to the deficit recovery liability can be found in note 22.
The College has also made available the National Employment Savings Trust for employees who are eligible under automatic enrolment regulations to pension benefits but not eligible for either USS or OSPS.
Schemes accounted for under FRS 102 as defined contribution schemes Deficit Recovery Plans
Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS)
A deficit recovery plan was put in place as part of the 2020 valuation, which required payment of 6.2% of salaries over the period 1 April 2022 until 31 March 2024, at which point the rate would increase to 6.3%. No deficit recovery plan was required under the 2023 valuation because the scheme was in surplus on a technical provisions basis. The College was no longer required to make deficit recovery contributions from 1 January 2024 and accordingly released the outstanding provision to the income and expenditure account. The latest available complete actuarial valuation of the Retirement Income Builder is as at 31 March 2023 (the valuation date), which was carried out using the projected unit method.
Since the College cannot identify its share of USS Retirement Income Builder (defined benefit) assets and liabilities, the following disclosures reflect those relevant for those assets and liabilities as a whole.
At 31 July 2023, the College’s balance sheet included a liability of £1.803m for future contributions, following the 2020 valuation when the scheme was in deficit. No deficit recovery plan was required from the 2023 valuation, because the scheme was in surplus. Changes to contribution rates were implemented from 1 January 2024 and from that date the College was no longer required to make deficit recovery contributions. The remaining liability of £1.803m was released to the income and expenditure account.
The 2023 valuation was the seventh valuation for the scheme under the scheme-specific funding regime introduced by the Pensions Act 2004, which requires schemes to have sufficient and appropriate assets to cover their technical provisions (the statutory funding objective). At the valuation date, the value of the assets of the scheme was £73.1 billion and the value of the scheme’s technical provisions was £65.7 billion indicating a surplus of £7.4 billion and a funding ratio of 111%.
The key financial assumptions used in the 2023 valuation are described below.
| CPI assumption | Term dependent rates in line with the difference between the Fixed Interest and Index Linked yield curves less: 1.0% p.a. to 2030, reducing linearly by 0.1% p.a. from 2030. |
|---|---|
| Benefits with no cap: CPI assumption plus 3bps Benefits subject to a “soft cap” of 5% (providing | |
| Pension increases (subject to a floor of 0%) | inflationary increases up to 5%, and half of any excess inflation over 5% up to a maximum of |
| 10%): CPI assumption minus 3bps | |
| Fixed interest gilt yield curve plus: | |
| Discount rate (forward rates) | Pre-retirement: 2.5% p.a. |
| Post-retirement: 0.9%p.a. |
The main demographic assumptions used relate to the mortality assumptions. These assumptions are based on analysis of the scheme’s experience carried out as part of the 2020 actuarial valuation. The mortality assumptions used in these figures are as follows:
| Mortality base table | 101% of S2PMA “light” for males and 95% of S3PFA for females | |
|---|---|---|
| Future improvements to mortality | CMI 2021 with a smoothing parameter of 7.5, an initial addition of 0.4% p.a. and a long-term improvement rate of 1.8% pa for males and 1.6% pa for females |
|
| The current life expectancies on retirement at age 65 are: | 2024 | 2023 |
| • Males currently aged 65 (years) | 23.7 | 24.0 |
| • Females currently aged 65 (years) | 25.6 | 25.6 |
| • Males currently aged 45 (years) | 25.4 | 26.0 |
| • Females currently aged 45 (years) | 27.2 | 27.4 |
43
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
22 PENSION SCHEMES (continued)
University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme
The University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme (OSPS) is a multi-employer hybrid scheme set up under trust and sponsored by the University. It is the pension scheme for support staff at the University, participating colleges and other related employers. New members joining the scheme build up benefits on a defined contribution basis. Members who joined before 1st October 2017 build up benefits on a career average revalued earnings basis.
The latest full actuarial valuation for the OSPS scheme was completed as at 31 March 2022. The funding position of this scheme has improved significantly moving from deficit of £113m to a surplus of £47m at the valuation date. As a result, the recovery plan agreed at the last valuation is no longer required and the deficit contribution ended on 30th September 2023. A provision of £26k was made at 31 July 2023 (2022: £755k) to account for deficit recovery payments up to 30th September 2023. That remaining liability of £26k was released to the income and expenditure account in 2024.
The Trustee and the University have agreed a new contribution schedule which took effect from 1 October 2023 and takes account of the benefit improvements and changes to member contributions since the last valuation date. It was agreed that the scheme will meet its own running costs from the scheme's assets, including expenses relating to both the DB and DC Sections and the cost of pension Protection Fund /other statutory levies.
The table below summarises the key actuarial assumptions. Further details of the assumptions are set out in the statement of funding principles dated 27 June 2023 and can be found at https://finance.admin.ox.ac.uk/osps-documents
| The table below summarises the key actuarial assumptions. Further details of the assumptions are set out in the statement of funding principles dated 27 June 2023 and can be found at https://finance.admin.ox.ac.uk/osps-documents |
The table below summarises the key actuarial assumptions. Further details of the assumptions are set out in the statement of funding principles dated 27 June 2023 and can be found at https://finance.admin.ox.ac.uk/osps-documents |
|---|---|
| 31/03/2022 £914m £961m £47m Value of assets: Funding surplus / (deficit) Value of liabilities: Date of valuation: |
|
| The principal assumptions used by the actuary were: | |
| Rate of interest(periods upto retirement) | Gilts' +2.25% |
| Rate of interest(periods after retirement) | Gilts' +0.5% |
| RPI | Break-even RPI curve less 0.5% pa pre-2030 and 1.0% pa post-2030 |
| CPI | RPI inflation assumption less 1% pa pre-2030 and 0.1% pa post- 2030 |
| Pensionable Salaryincreases | RPI +pa |
| FundingRatios: | |
| Technicalprovisions basis: | 105% |
| Buy-out' basis: | 62% |
| Non-financial assumptions: | |
| Post-retirement mortality - base table | Non-Pensioners: 105% of standard S3PxA medium tables for both males and females Pensioners: 105% of standard S3PxA medium tables for both males and females |
| Post-retirement mortality - improvements | Non-Pensioners: 105% of standard S3PxA medium tables for both males and females Pensioners: 105% of standard S3PxA medium tables for both males and females |
| Recommended employer’s contribution rate (as % of pensionable salaries): | 16.5% DB for members from 01/10/2023 10% /12% /14% DC members in relation to 4% /6% /8% cost plan - from 01/10/2023 |
| Effective date of next valuation: | 31/03/2025 |
A provision of £nil has been made at 31 July 2024 (2023: £1.829m) for the present value of the estimated future deficit funding element of the contributions payable under these agreements, using the assumptions shown.
Pension charge for the year
The pension charge recorded by the College during the accounting period (excluding pension finance costs) was equal to the contributions payable after allowance for the deficit recovery plan as follows:
Scheme
| Scheme | ||
|---|---|---|
| Universities Superannuation Scheme ('USS') University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme ('OSPS') National Employment Savings Trust (‘NEST’) |
2024 £'000 (1,255) 443 8 (804) |
2023 £'000 374 (161) 5 |
| 218 |
The amount expected to be paid in pension contributions in the following year is £1,181k. This excludes any adjustment required for accounting for the present value for the additional contributions resulting from past service deficit agreements.
Included in other creditors and accruals are pension contributions payable of £nil (2023: £nil).
Balliol College is aware of the Virgin Media v NTL Pension Trustees II Limited Court of Appeal judgement which may give rise to adjustments to USS and OSPS. At present the legal process is incomplete and therefore we are unable to quantify any potential liabilities.
44
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
23 TAXATION
The College is able to take advantage of the tax exemptions available to charities from taxation in respect of income and capital gains received to the extent that such income and gains are applied to exclusively charitable purposes. No liability to corporation tax arises in the College's subsidiary company because the directors of this company have indicated that they intend to make donations each year to the College equal to the taxable profits of the company under the Gift Aid scheme. Accordingly no provision for taxation has been included in the financial statements.
24 RECONCILIATION OF NET INCOME / (EXPENDITURE) TO NET CASH FLOW FROM OPERATING ACTIVITIES
| Net income/(expenditure) for the reporting year Adjustments for the elimination of non-operating cash flows: Investment income Unrealised (gains)/losses in investments Endowment donations Depreciation Decrease /(increase) in stock Decrease/ (increase) in debtors Increase / (decrease) in pension provision Increase / (decrease) in creditors Net cash (used in) / provide by operating activities |
2024 Group £'000 11,656 (3,337) (10,723) (422) 2,015 (2) (1,053) (1,829) 274 (3,421) |
2023 Group £'000 (561) (3,010) 4,197 (5,026) 1,981 (13) (541) 1,829 (2,608) |
|---|---|---|
| (3,752) |
25 ANALYSIS OF CHANGES IN NET DEBT
| Cash Loans falling due after more than one year Total ANALYSIS OF CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS Cash at bank and in hand Total cash and cash equivalents OPERATING LEASE COMMITMENTS At 31 July the College had annual commitments under non-cancellable operating leas Annual commitments for operating leases (equipment and motor vehicle) Expiring within one year Expiring between two and five years Expiring in over five years |
At start of the year £'000 3,634 (34,740) (31,106) es as follows: |
Cashflows £'000 (962) - (962) |
Foreign exchange movements £'000 5 - 5 |
Fair value and valuation movements £'000 - (3) (3) 2024 £'000 2,677 2,677 2024 £'000 32 22 - 54 |
At end of year £'000 2,677 (34,743) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (32,066) | |||||
| 2023 £'000 3,634 |
|||||
| 3,634 | |||||
| 2023 £'000 37 51 - |
|||||
| 88 |
- 26 ANALYSIS OF CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS
27 OPERATING LEASE COMMITMENTS
28 CAPITAL COMMITMENTS
At the year end there was a capital commitment of £79k for capital improvements on a residential property owned by the College (2023: nil).
29 RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
The College is part of the collegiate University of Oxford. Material interdependencies between the University and of the College arise as a consequence of this relationship. For reporting purposes, the University and the other Colleges are not treated as related parties as defined in FRS 102.
Members of the Governing Body, who are the trustees of the College and related parties as defined by FRS 102, receive remuneration and facilities as employees of the College. Details of these payments and reimbursed expenses as trustees are disclosed separately in these financial statements.
At the beginning of the year a trustee had a loan outstanding from the College of £150k under the Joint Equity/Loan Housing Scheme. The loan is repayable on the departure of the trustee from the College and is included in fixed asset investments. Three new Joint Equity schemes were entered into during the year for £300k each. The Joint Equity schemes will ceases on the departure of the trustee from the College and are included in fixed asset investments. In addition, one trustee has a short term loan from the College for the development of a property. At the year end £nil (2023: £2k) was outstanding and is included in 'Amounts owed by College members'. Trustee loans are subject to interest charged by the College.
Nursery facilities are made available to Trustees for a fee on the same basis as other College employees.
45
Balliol College Notes to the financial statements For the year ended 31 July 2024
30 CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
There are no contingent liabilities that require disclosure.
31 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS
There are no post balance sheet events that require disclosure.
32 COMPARATIVE INFORMATION
The split of income and expenditure per type of fund for the year ended 31 July 2023 was as follows:
| INCOME AND ENDOWMENTS FROM: Charitable activities: Teaching, research and residential Other trading income Donations and legacies Investments Investment income Total return allocated to income Other income Total income EXPENDITURE ON: Charitable activities: Teaching, research and residential Raising funds: Fundraising Trading expenditure Investment management costs Total expenditure Net (expenditure) / income before gains Net gains on investments Net (expenditure) / income |
Unrestricted Funds £'000 8,147 2,606 641 236 1,480 113 13,223 10,715 719 1,798 |
Restricted Funds £'000 - - 1,899 - 3,533 813 6,245 5,350 - - 5,350 895 - 895 |
Endowment Funds £'000 52 - 5,026 2,774 (5,013) - 2,839 89 - - 89 2,750 (4,197) (1,447) |
2023 Total £'000 8,199 2,606 7,566 3,010 - 926 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22,307 16,154 - - 719 1,798 - |
||||
| 13,232 (9) - (9) |
18,671 | |||
| 3,636 | ||||
| (4,197) | ||||
| (561) |
46